Answerman - Do Cultural Differences Justify Watsuki's Punishment?
- ️Tue Mar 18 2025
News chronological archives
- 21:41 Bleach: Rebirth of Souls Game's New Trailer Previews Ichigo Kurosaki's Final Form
- 21:15 'Long Story Short, I'm Living in the Mountains' Manga to End in 4th Volume
- 21:02 Anji Matono Ends 100 Ghost Stories That Will Lead to My Death Manga
- 20:49 Island of Giant Insects Sequel Manga to End in Next Installment
- 20:27 Cross Infinite World Leaves Bookwalker Global After Latter's Ownership Change
- 19:40 Aniplex, Crunchyroll Establish Joint Venture for Anime Production
- 10:00 Private Tutor to the Duke's Daughter Anime's Teaser Unveils July Debut
- 07:58 Voice Actor Shiki Aoki Goes on Hiatus Due to Health
- 06:37 Though I Am an Inept Villainess Light Novels' TV Anime Confirmed
- 06:10 The Unaware Atelier Master Anime's New Video Reveals More Cast, March 30 Advance Streaming
Convention reports chronological archives
- Dec 9 Getting Summoned to the Premiere of Headhunted to Another World: From Salaryman to Big Four!
- Dec 9 The Cat-astrophic Premiere of Beheneko: The Elf-Girl's Cat is Secretly an S-Ranked Monster!
- Dec 9 From Bureaucrat to Villainess: Dad's Been Reincarnated!'s Premiere Episode is Just as Funny as it Sounds
Newsfeed
Interest chronological archives
- Mar 14 Happy White Day From Around the Anime World, Part II
- Mar 14 Happy White Day From Around the Anime World, Part I
- Mar 14 Latest Chibi Maruko-chan Beer Ad Finally Reunites Trio in New York Bar
- Mar 13 Nue's Exorcist Tops AnimeJapan's 'Manga We Want to See Animated' Poll
- Mar 13 Shohei Otani Slides Into Fortnite Battle Royale
- Mar 12 Yamato Anime Marks 50th Anniversary With Solid-Gold Sculpture
- Mar 12 Hololive Announces 2 New Video Games
Press Releases chronological archives
- 17:03 Japanese Boys Group Wolf Howl Harmony Release Music Video for ‘BAKUON’, Lead Track from Debut Album ‘Wolf’! Epic Scale Video Shows Resolve to Go Bigger than Major
- 16:55 Koei Tecmo Releases Public Demo for Atelier Yumia: The Alchemist of Memories & the Envisioned Land
- 16:50 AiNA THE END New Single ‘Peerless Flowers’ Out Now! Check Out New Music Video Too
- 16:45 Aniplex, Crunchyroll Establish Anime Production Joint Venture, HAYATE
- 16:41 Kaiju No. 8: Mission Recon Coming to UK, Irish Cinemas on 16th April
- 07:29 Crunchyroll Acquires New Monster-Sized Cinematic Experience Kaiju No. 8: Mission Recon and Sets India Theatrical Date
Features chronological archives
- 11:30 I Watched It For The Story
- Mar 15 Your Anime Rankings - Best of Winter 2025, Mar 5-11
- Mar 14 Sword Art Online Illustrator BUNBUN Celebrates 20th Anniversary Exhibition
- Mar 13 Newtype Exclusive Interview with Composer Kaoru Wada: Crafting the Soundscape of Ranma ½
- Mar 12 Sailor Moon: The Super Live Cast Interview
- Mar 10 Interview: Zero Escape's Kotaro Uchikoshi on Ever 17 and Never 7 Finally Coming West
- Mar 9 Your Anime Rankings - Best of Winter 2025, Feb 26-Mar 4
- Mar 7 Getting Started with K-Comics - Tapas
- Mar 5 Hana-Kimi Exhibition Celebrates Hisaya Nakajo's 30th Career Anniversary
Reviews alphabetical archives
- 12:00 Corpse Blade Volume 1 Manga Review
- Mar 16 Men of the Harem Volume 1 K-Comic Review
- Mar 16 Mr. Mega Man Manga Review
- Mar 15 Mononoke The Movie: The Ashes of Rage Anime Film Review
- Mar 14 Welcome to Ghost Mansion Manga Volume 1 Review
- Mar 14 Atelier Yumia: The Alchemist of Memories & the Envisioned Land
- Mar 13 The Obsessed Mage and His Beloved Statue Bride Novel Review
- Mar 12 The Revenge of My Youth Manga Review
- Mar 11 I Want to Love You Till Your Dying Day Manga Review
Columns chronological archives
- 10:00 Answerman - Do Cultural Differences Justify Watsuki's Punishment?
- Mar 13 This Week in Anime - Anime Strike Out
- Mar 8 This Week in Games - Suikoden Returns
- Mar 4 The ANN Aftershow - Happy Late Cat-Day Stream!
- Feb 28 The Anime Backlog - Yu Yu Hakusho Season 1
Newtype... chronological archives
- Mar 13 Newtype Exclusive Interview with Composer Kaoru Wada: Crafting the Soundscape of Ranma ½
- Feb 11 Newtype Exclusive Interview with Creators Behind ONE PIECE FAN LETTER - Part 2
- Feb 4 Newtype Exclusive Interview with Creators Behind ONE PIECE FAN LETTER - Part 1
Everything chronological archives
- Features (incl. Interviews and Newtype, and also as Seasonal features like Anime Spotlight, Preview Guide, Weekly Rankings)
- Reviews (incl. Game Reviews)
- Current Columns (incl. Answerman, Intern Annika, The ANN Aftershow, The Anime Backlog, This Week in Anime, This Week in Games)
- Archived Columns (incl. ANNCast, ANNtv, Anime News Nina!, Astro Toy, Brain Diving, Buried Treasure, Chicks On Anime, Crashing Japan, Epic Threads, From The Gallery, Hai Fidelity, House of 1000 Manga, Ima Kore Ga Hoshiin Da, Old School, Pile of Shame, RIGHT TURN ONLY!!, Shelf Life, Sound Decision, Sub Culture, Super Plastic, Tales Of The Industry, Tankobon Tower, The Click, The Dub Track, The Edit List, The Gallery, The List, The Mike Toole Show, The Set List, The Stream, The X Button, Vice & Luna)
- Editorials (incl. Industry Comments)
- Advertorials
- Your Score: Rate the Latest Simulcasts
- Upcoming Anime List
- Upcoming DVD & Blu-ray
- Weekly Rankings: The Best and Worst of the Season So Far According to Readers
Anime Spotlight
- » previous seasons
Winter 2025 Preview Guide
- The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, Really Love You Season 2
- Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective
- Anyway, I'm Falling in Love with You.
- The Apothecary Diaries Season 2
- Aquarion: Myth of Emotions
- Ave Mujica - The Die is Cast -
- Baban Baban Ban Vampire
- Beheneko: The Elf-Girl's Cat is Secretly an S-Ranked Monster!
- Blue Exorcist: The Blue Night Saga
- Bogus Skill <<fruitmaster>>
- The Daily Life of a Middle-Aged Online Shopper in Another World
- Dr. STONE SCIENCE FUTURE
- Even Given the Worthless "Appraiser" Class, I'm Actually the Strongest
- Farmagia
- FLOWER AND ASURA
- From Bureaucrat to Villainess: Dad's Been Reincarnated!
- Grisaia: Phantom Trigger the Animation
- Headhunted to Another World: From Salaryman to Big Four!
- Honey Lemon Soda
- I Left My A-Rank Party
- I May Be a Guild Receptionist
- I Want to Escape from Princess Lessons
- I'm a Noble on the Brink of Ruin, So I Might as Well Try Mastering Magic
- I'm Getting Married to a Girl I Hate in My Class
- I'm Living with an Otaku NEET Kunoichi!?
- Ishura Season 2
- Kinnikuman: Perfect Origin Arc Season 2
- Magic Maker: How to Make Magic in Another World
- Medaka Kuroiwa Is Impervious to My Charms
- Medalist
- Momentary Lily
- My Happy Marriage Season 2
- OKITSURA: Fell in Love with an Okinawan Girl, but I Just Wish I Know What She's Saying
- Possibly the Greatest Alchemist of All Time
- Promise of Wizard
- The Red Ranger Becomes an Adventurer in Another World
- Sakamoto Days
- Solo Leveling Season 2 -Arise from the Shadow-
- Sorairo Utility
- Tasokare Hotel
- Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun Season 2
- Unnamed Memory Act.2
- Welcome to Japan, Ms. Elf!
- ZENSHU
- Übel Blatt
- » previous seasons
-
Daily Streaming Reviews
- Ameku M.D.: Doctor Detective #9
- Ave Mujica - The Die is Cast - #11
- Beheneko: The Elf-Girl's Cat is Secretly an S-Ranked Monster! #12
- Blue Box #22-23
- Blue Exorcist: The Blue Night Saga #11
- Dr. STONE SCIENCE FUTURE #10
- Flower and Asura #10
- From Bureaucrat to Villainess: Dad's Been Reincarnated! #10
- Honey Lemon Soda #10
- I May Be a Guild Receptionist #10
- Is It Wrong to Try to Pick Up Girls in a Dungeon? V #15
- Medalist #11
- Momentary Lily #10-11
- My Happy Marriage Season 2 #24
- One Piece Log: Fish-Man Island Saga #18
- Orb: On the Movements of the Earth #25
- Re:ZERO -Starting Life in Another World- Season 3 #64
- Sakamoto Days #10
- Shangri-La Frontier Season 2 #48
- Solo Leveling Season 2 -Arise from the Shadow- #23
- Tasokare Hotel #11
- The 100 Girlfriends Who Really, Really, Really, Really, Really Love You Season 2 #22
- The Apothecary Diaries Season 2 #34
- The Red Ranger Becomes an Adventurer in Another World #9
- Toilet-Bound Hanako-kun Season 2 #10
- Übel Blatt #10
- Welcome to Japan, Ms. Elf! #9-10
- Witchy Precure! -MIRAI DAYS- #10
- ZENSHU. #10
- No account yet? Registering is free, easy, and private. Discuss in the forum, contribute to the Encyclopedia, build your own MyAnime lists, and more.
Answerman
Do Cultural Differences Justify Watsuki's Punishment?
by Jerome Mazandarani, Mar 17th 2025

James J. asks:
Dear Mr. Answerman,This may be a serious subject, but I have noticed that some American fans believe that Nobuhiro Watsuki's punishment was too lenient, and, as an American, myself, I can fully understand that sentiment, but Japan is a radically different country with a very different culture from the United States, so I believe that Americans should not judge Watsuki by the standards of their own culture. If the Japanese government and people believe that his punishment was sufficient, then I believe that other people should accept that, as well.
What do you think about this? Is this too controversial a subject to post on ANN's website?
Thank you very much.
The question of Nobuhiro Watsuki's punishment for possessing child sexual abuse material (“CSAM”) has sparked a significant debate, particularly among non-Japanese fans. To put it bluntly: yes, by our standards, his punishment was undeniably too lenient. This isn't a matter of cultural insensitivity, but a reflection of deeply held values regarding child protection.
It's crucial to acknowledge that Japanese culture differs radically from Western, particularly American culture. These differences extend to our legal systems and societal attitudes toward crime and punishment. You have suggested that we should defer to the Japanese system's judgment, arguing that their government and people deemed the punishment sufficient. However, I fundamentally disagree.
While respecting cultural differences is important, we cannot abdicate our moral standards. CSAM is a universally abhorrent crime. To suggest we should simply accept a lenient punishment because it aligns with another culture's norms is to minimize the severity of the offense.
The Japanese legal system's approach, as evidenced by Watsuki's case, appears to prioritize rehabilitation and societal reintegration, often through fines and probation, rather than lengthy prison sentences. This contrasts sharply with Western systems, where such crimes often carry severe penalties.
You seem to allude to the concept that the Japanese system has determined his guilt, but that a prison sentence was not necessary, and that he should be allowed to resume his life. I disagree. The fine Watsuki received feels like a mere slap on the wrist, especially considering the gravity of his crime. It sends a troubling message, particularly in a society grappling with sexual exploitation, and the normalization of the hypersexualization of underage girls in popular manga, anime, and video game works.
The lenient punishment also disregards the potential impact on victims, both known and unknown. Child sexual abuse material is not a victimless crime. It fuels a market of abuse and exploitation. The lack of a substantial penalty suggests a lack of regard for the harm inflicted.
The resumption of Watsuki's manga publication after his conviction further complicates the issue. While his publisher may have deemed it acceptable, it raises questions about accountability and sends a message that such actions are easily forgiven.
As consumers, we have the right to choose whether to support creators who have committed such offenses. Personally, I cannot reconcile enjoying the work of someone who has engaged in such reprehensible behavior.
The core issue is that child sexual abuse material is a heinous crime. It involves the sexual exploitation of minors, and its possession perpetuates this abuse. The legal definition of CSAM, as outlined in U.S. federal law, underscores its severity.
While Japan has revised its laws regarding sexual offenses, the discrepancy in sentencing remains stark. The fine levied against Watsuki pales in comparison to the potential prison sentences in the U.S. for similar offenses.
The Japanese legal system's emphasis on rehabilitation and reintegration, as described by Professor Kawai Mikio, offers insight into this disparity. However, this approach does not absolve the offender of responsibility.
The Japanese system's high conviction rate and reliance on confessions suggest a different approach to criminal justice. While societal pressure and rehabilitation efforts may contribute to lower re-offending rates, they do not justify lenient punishments for serious crimes.
The question of whether Japanese society as a whole accepts Watsuki's punishment remains unanswered. The entertainment industry's tendency to handle scandals discreetly makes it difficult to gauge public sentiment, but as the recent Fuji TV fallout suggests, advertisers are no longer prepared to continue supporting shoddily run corporations when it comes to sexual misconduct scandals.
It's also worth noting the demographic differences within the Japanese judicial and political systems, particularly the lack of female representation (Less than 16% of sitting representatives in the Diet currently are women), which may influence attitudes toward sexual offenses.
While acknowledging cultural differences, we cannot ignore the fundamental principles of justice and child protection. To suggest that we should simply accept a lenient punishment because it aligns with another culture's norms is to minimize the severity of the offense.
Ultimately, Watsuki's conviction stands. He is a convicted offender, and his actions are reprehensible. Therefore, it is perfectly valid for individuals to choose not to support his work. The law, however imperfect, serves as a guide for societal responses to crime and punishment, and in this case, by our standards, that punishment was far too lenient.
Do YOU have a question for the Answerman?
We'd love to answer your questions and especially encourage questions inspired by recent news and headlines.
However, READ THIS FIRST:
● CHECK THE ARCHIVES. Over the years, we've answered THOUSANDS of questions and might have already answered yours!
● We cannot tell you if or when a show will get another season, nor can we help you get in touch with any producers, artists, creators, actors, or licensors.
● Only submit your question once.
● We take questions by email only. (Tweeted questions get ignored!)
● Please keep your questions within a paragraph length.
●The email address is [email protected].
Thank you!
discuss this in the forum (32 posts) |