King Juan Carlos of Spain dishonors the Order of the Golden Fleece

Juan Carlos de Bourbon gives the Golden Fleece to Muslim Abullah of Arabia - Point de Vue, June 27, 2007

The Garter Order has a somewhat inauspicious origin. It was created by Edward III, King of England, during a ball given in Calais, France, when his mistress, the Countess of Salisbury, lost her garter during a dance. It fell to the floor in plain view of all there. How was that intimate piece loosened? What had she been doing a little before? The ladies and gentlemen present started to look at each other and imagine things.

Edward and his mistress could sense the gossip. To avoid the growing embarrassment, he picked up the garter, put it on his own leg, and turning to the assembly, uttered this “sublime” phrase: "Honi soit qui mal y pense" – Shamed be the one who thinks evil of this. In fact his words explained nothing. They just expressed a command: “Stop this, or I will become angry.”

The nobility present actually stopped gossiping in order not to displease such an important personage. The Countess of Salisbury squeezed out of a difficult situation, and the English King, surprised at his unusual presence of mind, founded an order to perpetuate his gesture and his adultery. It is difficult to imagine that from this spirit a crusade could come. And, in fact, it didn’t.

Further, in 1534 this order became Protestant with Henry VIII’s rejection of Catholicism. It was still a noble order until Queen Elizabeth II resolved to “modernize” it, making snooker champions and soccer players members. This year (2007), the latest of these celebrities to be granted such an honor was the author of Satanic Verses, the Indian writer Salman Rushdie, who should now be addressed as “Sir.” If anything worthwhile of the Order remained, it is quickly dying.

Philip the Good, Duke of Bourgogne, founder of the Order

Some historians link this initiative to an invitation he received in 1422 to become a member of the Order of the Garter. He declined the honor and instead, eight years later on January 10, 1430 when he married Princess Isabel of Portugal, he founded the Order of the Golden Fleece. The Garter Order was established to celebrate a royal adultery, Philip III made the Golden Fleece to celebrate a royal Catholic marriage: French panache.

The Order was exclusively for Catholics. Further, we can see that the desire to defend the Church was clearly present in Philip’s mind from his own words explaining its purpose:

Pour maintenir l’Eglise qui est de Dieu maison,
J’ai mis sus le noble Ordre, qu’on nome Toison

To support the Church, which is the House of God,
I established the noble Order that is called the Fleece.

In those Renaissance times, alas, it was not rare to mix Catholic ideals with pagan symbols. Thus, the Greek legend of Jason and his daring quest for the magic golden fleece that would allow him to regain the throne of Iolsus from Pelias, his usurper uncle, was chosen as the symbol of that nascent order.

How could a Catholic order be symbolized by a pagan hero? Many reactions rose up against it. Cardinal Guillaume Fillastre, however, would “baptize” Jason, linking him with the Biblical heroes Jacob and Gideon, pretending that the three of them would represent magnificence, justice and prudence. Also Fr. Raoul de Fèvre, chaplain of Charles the Fearless, wrote the Romance of Jason, in which the Greek prince was transformed into a medieval knight who was sad because of the dishonor of the world around him and set out to repair it.

The magnificence of the House of Bourgogne – more brilliant than any royal house of the time – was transferred to the Order of the Golden Fleece. In many ways Philip’s son, Charles the Fearless, represented the apogee of the House of Bourgogne as well as its end. His constant rivalry with King Louis XI of France can be called the battle of the last medieval knight against the first bourgeois king, the fight of idealism and dedication against intrigue and mediocrity. This was celebrated in historic novels by Sir Walter Scott and Alexandre Dumas.

Neck chain of a knight of the Golden Fleece Order

The Austrian branch has 50 members, all Catholic and noble, to my knowledge. The Order is ruled by Prince Otto von Habsburg, the de jure heir of the Austrian-Hungarian Empire.

The Spanish branch is ruled by Juan Carlos, King of Spain, and has 17 members. Juan Carlos, however, has introduced innovations that have denigrated the Order. Against its tradition as a Catholic Order, he made non-Catholics members: one Schismatic, Constantin of Greece; five Protestants, Elizabeth of England, Carl Gustaf of Sweden, Beatrix of the Netherlands, Margaret of Denmark, and Harald of Norway; two Buddhists, Akihito of Japan and Bhumidol of Thailand. And now, on June 18 of this year, he made a Muslim member – Abdullah of Saudi Arabia.

By offering the Golden Fleece, whose purpose was to defend the Church primarily against the Mohammedans, to one of the Muslim’s more important representatives today, Juan Carlos completely dishonors one of the most prestigious honorific orders of Christendom.

Reparation for such a betrayal of the ideal of Chivalry made by a reigning Catholic King is in order.