ballotpedia.org

California judicial elections, 2010

From Ballotpedia

Judicial Elections
Ballotpedia Election Coverage Badge.png
Elections, 2010
Primary election dates, 2010
Find your state


The California judicial elections of 2010 consisted of a Nonpartisan Election on November 2, 2010, and countywide primaries on June 8 for contested Superior Court judgeships. In these primaries, any candidate who received over 50% of the vote proceeded uncontested to the November general election; if no candidate received over 50% of the vote, the top two vote-winners competed in the general election. In California, only Superior Court judges are elected. Supreme Court and Court of Appeal justices are nominated by the Governor, confirmed by the California Commission on Judicial Appointments, and then must be retained by the voters in the next general election, and once again every twelve years, if they are to remain on the bench. Superior Court judges serve six-year terms; Supreme Court and Court of Appeal justices serve 12-year terms.[1]

Overview

Three Supreme Court and 35 Courts of Appeal justices were up for retention in 2010, and 399 Superior Court judges were up for re-election. Of these 399 seats, only 38 were contested in the June 8 primary, and only nine were be contested in the November 2 general election.

Supreme Court

After appointment, California Supreme Court justices are elected via retention election for a 12 year term at the next general election. Chief Justice Ronald George retired at the end of his present term and did not seek retention in November. In anticipation of his retirement, Tani Cantil-Sakauye was appointed to the Chief Justiceship, and was retained this November. She will assume the seat George will be vacating in January 2011, when his current term ends.[2] Justices Ming Chin and Carlos Moreno sought retention in the November 2, 2010 general election.

In 2010, three justices' 12 year terms were ending:[3]

Courts of Appeal

35 California Courts of Appeal justices were up for a retention election in 2010.[3]

Court Candidate Results
First District, Division One Kathleen M. Banke Retained with 77% of the vote.
First District, Division One Robert L. Dondero Retained with 73.5% of the vote.
First District, Division Two James Lambden Retained with 74.2% of the vote.
First District, Division Three Martin J. Jenkins Retained with 76.4% of the vote.
First District, Division Three Peter Siggins Retained with 72.3% of the vote.
First District, Division Four Timothy Reardon Retained with 77% of the vote.
First District, Division Five Terence L. Bruiniers Retained with 73.9% of the vote.
First District, Division Five Henry E. Needham Retained with 74.7% of the vote.
Second District, Division One Robert Mallano Retained with 67.9% of the vote.
Second District, Division One Victoria Gerrard Chaney Retained with 70% of the vote.
Second District, Division One Jeffrey W. Johnson Retained with 66.3% of the vote.
Second District, Division Two Judith Ashmann-Gerst Retained with 66.7% of the vote.
Second District, Division Three Walter Croskey Retained with 63.6% of the vote.
Second District, Division Four Steven Suzukawa Retained with 68.2% of the vote.
Second District, Division Five Orville Armstrong Retained with 71% of the vote.
Second District, Division Six Paul Coffee Retained with 70.8% of the vote.
Second District, Division Six Steven Perren Retained with 67.2% of the vote.
Second District, Division Seven Laurie Zelon Retained with 66.2% of the vote.
Second District, Division Seven Frank Jackson Retained with 69.7% of the vote.
Second District, Division Eight Patricia Bigelow Retained with 70.9% of the vote.
Second District, Division Eight Elizabeth A. Grimes Retained with 72.5% of the vote.
Third District George Nicholson Retained with 71.7% of the vote.
Third District Harry Hull Retained with 68.1% of the vote.
Third District Kathleen Butz Retained with 69.6% of the vote.
Fourth District, Division One Judith McConnell (California) Retained with 70.7% of the vote.
Fourth District, Division Two Manuel A. Ramirez Retained with 68.7% of the vote.
Fourth District, Division Two Carol D. Codrington Retained with 73.6% of the vote.
Fourth District, Division Three David Sills Retained with 71.2% of the vote.
Fourth District, Division Three William Bedsworth Retained with 73.3% of the vote.
Fourth District, Division Three Eileen Moore Retained with 70.2% of the vote.
Fifth District Brad Hill Retained with 71.9% of the vote.
Fifth District Jennifer R.S. Detjen Retained with 69.5% of the vote.
Fifth District Chuck Poochigian Retained with 70.1% of the vote.
Fifth District Bert Levy Retained with 70.8% of the vote.
Sixth District Conrad Rushing Retained with 75.7% of the vote.

[4]

Superior Courts

Because of the large number of California Superior Court terms ending this year, the counties have been split into two pages. Please visit the pages linked to below to learn more about all the incumbent judges with terms ending this year. 399 Superior Court judge-ships throughout the state of California had terms expire in 2010; only 38 of these 399 seats were contested in the June 8 primary, and only nine seats were contested in the November 2 general election. The following table lists those races which were be contested. Those 361 incumbents who were unchallenged in the primary did not need to participate in a runoff election, and could have only lost their seats to write-in campaigns. Moreover, California Elections Code § 8203 dictates that no Superior Court judge who was unopposed in the primary will have his or her name placed on the November ballot unless a petition signed by 100 voters qualified to vote for or against that judge be submitted "not less than 83 days before the general election," which, in this election cycle, was August 11.[5][6] Further, the Elections Code requires that, for a write-in vote to be counted, the person for whom the vote is cast must have filed a statement of candidacy between 14 and 57 days prior to the election. This year these dates fell on Monday, September 6, and Tuesday, October 19.[5][7]

November 2 general results

Court Incumbent November 2 Candidates General Results Winner
Alameda County Superior Court VACANT John Creighton and Victoria Kolakowski Victoria Kolakowski (50.24%), John Creighton (48.75%)[8] Victoria Kolakowski
Los Angeles Superior Court Number 28 Emily A. Stevens (Did not run) Mark K. Ameli and Randy Hammock Randy Hammock (52.50%); Mark K. Ameli (47.50%)[9] Randy Hammock
Los Angeles Superior Court Number 117 William R. Pounders (Did not run) Thomas J. Griego and Alan K. Schneider Alan K. Schneider (59.80%); Thomas J. Griego (40.20%)[9] Alan K. Schneider
Mono County Superior Court VACANT[10] Randall L. Gephart and Mark Magit Mark Magit (53.57%); Randall L. Gephart (46.43%)[11] Mark Magit
San Diego County Superior Court Number 20 Robert C. Coates (Did not run) Richard Monroy and Jim Miller, Jr. Richard Monroy (51.5%) and Jim Miller, Jr. (48.5%)[9] Richard Monroy
San Francisco County Superior Court Seat 15 Richard B. Ulmer, Jr. Michael Nava and Richard B. Ulmer, Jr. Michael Nava (47.74%); Richard B. Ulmer, Jr. (52.26%)[9] Richard B. Ulmer, Jr.
Sierra County Superior Court William W. Pangman (Did not run) Thomas S. Archer and Charles H. Ervin Thomas S. Archer (49.69%) and Charles H. Ervin (50.31%)[12] Charles H. Ervin
Sonoma County Superior Court Office 2 Lawrence G. Antolini (Did not run) Pat Broderick and John Lemmon Pat Broderick (56.7%); John Lemmon (42.9%)[9] Pat Broderick
Stanislaus County Superior Court Office Number 6 Nancy Williamsen and Shawn D. Bessey Shawn D. Bessey (54.68%); Nancy Wiliamsen (44.612%)[13] Shawn D. Bessey

June 8 primary results

Court Incumbent June 8 Primary Candidates Primary Results
Alameda County Superior Court VACANT John Creighton, Louis Goodman and Victoria Kolakowski Victoria Kolakowski (45.12%); John Creighton (32.17%)[14]
Los Angeles Superior Court Number 28 Emily A. Stevens (Did not run) Mark K. Ameli, Chris Garcia, Randy Hammock, Lou Holtz Jr., C. Edward Mack, Elizabeth Moreno, Edward J. Nison, Kendall C. Reed and Kim Smith[15] Randy Hammock (21.98%); Mark K. Ameli (14.46%)[9]
Los Angeles Superior Court Number 117 William R. Pounders (Did not run) Thomas J. Griego, Patricia M. Vienna, Alan K. Schneider and William M. Margolin Alan K. Schneider (42%); Thomas J. Griego (32%)[9]
Mono County Superior Court VACANT[16] Randall L. Gephart, Mark Magit and Therese Hankel Mark Magit (46.51%); Randall L. Gephart (43.35%)[17]
San Diego County Superior Court Number 20 Robert C. Coates (Did not run) Stephen P. Clark,[18] Jim Miller, Jr. and Richard Monroy Richard Monroy (39.43%); Jim Miller, Jr. (32.78%)[19]
San Francisco County Superior Court Seat 15 Richard B. Ulmer, Jr. Daniel Dean, Michael Nava and Richard B. Ulmer, Jr.[20] Michael Nava (45.52%); Richard B. Ulmer, Jr. (41.91%)[21]
Sierra County Superior Court William W. Pangman (Did not run) Thomas S. Archer, Charles H. Ervin, C. Ingrid Larson and Douglas M. Prouty[22] Thomas S. Archer (38.85%); Charles H. Ervin (30.73%)[23]
Sonoma County Superior Court Office 2 Lawrence G. Antolini (Did not run) Pat Broderick, James Patrick Casey, and John Lemmon[24] Pat Broderick (40.2%); John Lemmon (32.7%)[25]
Stanislaus County Superior Court Office Number 6 Nancy Williamsen, Martha Carlton-Magana, Shawn D. Bessey, William E. Mussman, Philip A. Pimentel and Geoffrey C. Hutcheson[26] Shawn D. Bessey (24.21%); Nancy Wiliamsen (21.12%)[27]

See also

External links

Footnotes

  1. Judge voter guide: California Courts Judicial Selection/Election/Retention Process
  2. Los Angeles Times, "California Supreme Court chief to retire," July 15, 2010
  3. 3.0 3.1 SOS Certified List of Candidates for the November 2, 2010, General Election (see pp 109-115)
  4. 4.0 4.1 California Secretary of State, November 2, 2010 Official Results
  5. 5.0 5.1 "Candidate Handbook and Resource Guide," General Election, November 2, 2010 (see Chapter 5, pp 57-58)
  6. California Elections Code; see 8203 (dead link)
  7. California Elections Code, §§ 8600-8605 (dead link)
  8. [1]
  9. 9.0 9.1 9.2 9.3 9.4 9.5 9.6 [2] Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "cbs" defined multiple times with different content Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "cbs" defined multiple times with different content Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "cbs" defined multiple times with different content Cite error: Invalid <ref> tag; name "cbs" defined multiple times with different content
  10. Mono County Superior Court website
  11. http://monocounty.ca.gov/departments/elections/documents/SemiFinalElection.pdf
  12. http://www.sierracounty.ws/county_docs/clk-rec/GEMS%20ELECTION%20SUMMARY%20REPORT%20-%20110210.pdf
  13. [3]
  14. Alameda County Election Results, Superior Court Judge, Office 9
  15. Metropolitan News-Enterprise "Four More Superior Court Candidates Receive ‘Qualified’ Ratings," May 4, 2010
  16. Mono County Superior Court website
  17. Mono County, Semi-Official Primary Election Summary Report
  18. Voice of San Diego "The Candidate Who Accepts No Contributions," May 27, 2010
  19. San Diego 6, San Diego County Full Election Results
  20. San Francisco County Department of Elections, Qualified Candidate List for June 8, 2010
  21. San Francisco County, Unofficial Primary Election Results
  22. Sierra County June 8, 2010 Official Local Candidate List
  23. Sierra County, Unofficial Final Results, Primary Election
  24. Petaluma 360: "Five candidates vie for two judicial seats," May 21, 2010
  25. Sonoma County, Primary Election Results
  26. Stanislaus County, Candidate List
  27. Stanislaus County, Primary Election Results (dead link)