Fire in the Virgin Forests of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area, Minnesota | Quaternary Research | Cambridge Core

Fire largely determined the composition and structure of the presettlement vegetation of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area as well as the vegetation mosaic on the landscape and the habitat patterns for wildlife. It also influenced nutrient cycles, and energy pathways, and helped maintain the diversity, productivity, and long-term stability of the ecosystem. Thus the whole ecosystem was fire-dependent.

At least some overstory elements in virtually all forest stands still date from regeneration that followed one or more fires since 1595 A.D. The average interval between significant fire years was about 4 yr in presettlement times, but shortened to 2 yr from 1868 to 1910 during settlement. However, 83% of the area burned before the beginning of suppression programs resulted from just nine fire periods: 1894, 1875, 1863–1964, 1824, 1801, 1755–1959, 1727, 1692, 1681. The average interval between these major fire years was 26 yr. Most present virgin forests date from regeneration that followed fires in these years. Significant areas were also regenerated by fires in 1903, 1910, 1936, and 1971. Most major fire years occurred during prolonged summer droughts of subcontinental extent, such as those of 1864, 1910, and 1936. Many fires were man-caused, but lightning ignitions were also common. Lightning alone is probably a sufficient source of ignitions to guarantee that older stands burned before attaining climax. Dry matter accumulations, spruce budworm outbreaks, blowdowns, and other interactions related to time since fire increase the probability that old stands will burn. Vegetation patterns on the landscape were influenced by such natural firebreaks as lakes, streams, wetlands, and moist slopes. Red and white pine are most common on islands, and to the east, northeast, or southeast of such firebreaks. Jack pine, aspen-birch, and sprout hardwood forests are most common on large uplands distant from or west of such firebreaks.

A Natural Fire Rotation of about 100 yr prevailed in presettlement times, but many red and white pine stands remained largely intact for 150–350 yr, and some jack pine and aspen-birch forests probably burned at intervals of 50 yr or less. There is paleoecological evidence that fire was an ecosystem factor before European man arrived, and even before early man migrated to North America. Probably few areas ever attained the postulated fir-spruce-cedar-birch climax in postglacial times. To understand the dynamics of fire-dependent ecosystems fire must be studied as an integral part of the system. The search for stable communities that might develop without fire is futile and avoids the real challenge of understanding nature on her own terms.

To restore the natural ecosystem of the Canoe Area fire should soon be reintroduced through a program of prescribed fires and monitored lightning fires. Failing this, major unnatural, perhaps unpredictable, changes in the ecosystem will occur.

Ahlgren, C.E., (1959). Some effects of fire on forest reproduction in northeastern Minnesota. Journal of Forestry 57, 194–200.Google Scholar

Ahlgren, C.E., (1960). Some effects of fire on reproduction and growth of vegetation in northeastern Minnesota. Ecology 41, 431–445.Google Scholar

Ahlgren, C.E., (1970). Some effects of prescribed burning on jack pine reproduction in northeastern Minnesota. University of Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station, Miscellaneous Report 94 14Forestry Series 5.Google Scholar

Ahlgren, I.F., Ahlgren, C.E., (1960). Ecological effects of forest firest. Botanical Review 26, 483–533.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Ahti, T., Hepburn, R.L., (1967). Preliminary studies of woodland caribou range, especially on lichen stands, in Ontario. Ontario Department of Lands and Forests, Research Report (Wildlife) 74, 66.Google Scholar

Anderson, R.L., Kaufert, F.H., (1959). Brooming response of black spruce to dwarf mistletoe infection. Forest Science 5, 356–364.Google Scholar

Ayres, H.B., (1899). Timber conditions of the pine region of Minnesota: Part I. Forest reserves. U.S. Geological Survey, 21st Annual Report 679–689with map.Google Scholar

Baker, D.G., Strub, J.H. Jr., (1965). Climate of Minnesota: Part III. Temperature and its application. University of Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station, Technical Bulletin 248, 64.Google Scholar

Baker, D.G., Haines, D.A., Strub, J.H. Jr., (1967). Climate of Minnesota: Part V. Precipitation: facts, normals, and extremes. University of Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station, Technical Bulletin 254, 44.Google Scholar

Barney, R.J., (1971). Wildfires in Alaska—some historical and projected effects and aspects. Fire in the Northern Environment—a Symposium Fairbanks, Alaska, 197151–59Proc.Google Scholar

Batzer, H.O., (1969). Forest character and vulnerability of balsam fir to spruce budworm in Minnesota. Forest Science 15, 1 17–25.Google Scholar

Beaufait, W.R., (1960). Some effects of high temperatures on the cones and seeds of jack pine. Forest Science 6, 194–199.Google Scholar

Beaufait, W.R., (1962). Procedures in prescribed burning for jack pine regeneration. Michigan College of Mining and Technology, Tech. Bull. 9 37.Google Scholar

Blais, J.R., (1965). Spruce budworm outbreaks in the past three centuries in the Laurentide Park, Quebec. Forest Science 11, 130–138.Google Scholar

Books, D.J., (1972). Little Sioux Burn: Year 2. Naturalist (Journal Natural History Society of Minnesota) 23, 2–7.Google Scholar

Braniff, E.A., (1903). The proposed Lake Superior Forest Reserve, Lake and Cook Counties, Minnesota. Official Report in files of Superior National Forest 8(typed).Google Scholar

Brower, D., (1960). The Meaning of Wilderness to Science. The Sierra Club San Francisco.Google Scholar

Buckman, R.E., (1964a). Silvicultural use of prescribed burning in the Lake States. Proc. Society of American Foresters Denver, Colo, 196438–40.Google Scholar

Buckman, R.E., (1964b). Effects of prescribed burning on hazel in Minnesota. Ecology 45, 626–629.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Buell, M.F., Niering, W.A., (1957). Fir-spruce-birch forest in northern Minnesota. Ecology 38, 602–610.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Cayford, J.H., (1971). The role of fire in the ecology and silviculture of jack pine. Proc. Tenth Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Fredericton, N.B., 221–244.Google Scholar

Clements, F.E., (1910). The life history of lodgepole burn forests. U.S. Forest Service, Bull. 79 56.Google Scholar

Cooper, W.S., (1913). The climax forest of Isle Royale, Lake Superior, and its development. Botanical Gazette 15, 1–44, 115–140, 189–235.Google Scholar

Craig, A.J., (1972). Pollen influx to laminated sediments: a pollen diagram from northeastern Minnesota. Ecology 53, 46–57.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Cringan, A.T., (1957). History, food, habits, and range requirements of the woodland caribou of Continental North America. Proc. North American Wildlife Conference, 22nd 485–501.Google Scholar

Dean, J.L., (1971). Wetland forest communities of the eastern Boundary Waters Canoe Area. M.S. Thesis University of Minnesota 101.Google Scholar

Dodge, M., (1972). Forest fuel accumulation—a growing problem. Science 177, 139–142.Google Scholar

Falls, B., (1967). The importance of wilderness to science. The Ontario Naturalist Dec. 1967.Google Scholar

Fenneman, N.M., (1938). Physiography of Eastern United States. McGraw Hill Book Co New York.Google Scholar

Fowells, H.A., (1965). Silvics of forest trees of the United States. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Agriculture Handbook No. 271 762.Google Scholar

Frissell, S.S. Jr., (1968). A fire chronology for Itasca State Park, Minnesota. University of Minnesota, Forest Research Note 196 .Google Scholar

Frissell, S.S. Jr., (1971). An analysis of the maintenance of pre-settlement biotic communities as an objective of management in Itasca State Park, Minnesota. Ph.D. Thesis 228, University of Minnesota.Google Scholar

Grange, W., (1965). Fire and tree growth relationships to snowshoe rabbits. Proc. Fourth Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Tallahassee, Florida, 110–125.Google Scholar

Grigal, D.F., Ohmann, L.F., (1973). Wilderness Ecology: the upland plant communities of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area. North Central Forest Experiment Station and University of MinnesotaUnpublished Manuscript.Google Scholar

Gunderson, H.L., Beer, J.R., (1953). The Mammals of Minnesota. University of Minnesota Press Minneapolis.Google Scholar

Haines, D.A., Sando, R.W., (1969). Climatic conditions preceding historically great fires in the North Central Region. Forest Service Research Paper NC-34 19.Google Scholar

Hegyi, F., (1972). Dry matter distribution in jack pine stands in northern Ontario. Forestry Chronicle 48, 193–197.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1957). Silvical characteristics of black spruce (Picea mariana). U.S. Forest Service, Lake States Forest Experiment Station Paper 45 30(processed).Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1963). Forest sites, bog processes, and peatland types in the Glacial Lake Agassiz region, Minnesota. Ecological Monographs 33, 327–374.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1965a). Vegetation management in wilderness areas and primitive parks. Journal of Forestry 63, 440–445.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1965b). Wilderness and National Park Management Goals. Journal of Forestry 63, 12Notes and comment.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1969). Diary of the Canoe Country's landscape. Naturalist (Journal Natural History Society of Minnesota) 20, 1 2–13.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1970a). Preserving nature in forested Wilderness Areas and National Parks. National Parks and Conservation Magazine 44, 276 8–14.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1970b). The natural role of fires in northern conifer forests. Symposium on “The role of fire in the Intermountain West”. Naturalist 21, Intermountain Fire Research Council 14–23(4).Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1970c). Landscape evolution, peatland types, and the environment in the Lake Agassiz Peatlands Natural Area, Minnesota. Ecological Monographs 40, 235–261.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., (1971). Restoring fire to the ecosystems of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area, Minnesota. Proc. Tenth Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Fredericton, N.B., 9–23.Google Scholar

Heinselman, M.L., Roe, E.I., (1963). A record of some Pleistocene trees and shrubs from Itasca County, Minnesota. Forest Science 9, 336–337.Google Scholar

Higgins, S.M., (1908). Additional area to the proposed Lake Superior National Forest, Minnesota. U.S. Forest Service 9(typed).Google Scholar

Irving, F.D., French, D.W., (1971). Control by fire of dwarf mistletoe in black spruce. Journal of Forestry 69, 28–30.Google Scholar

Irving, W.N., Harington, C.R., (1973). Upper Pleistocene radiocarbon-dated artifacts from the northern Yukon. Science 179, 335–340.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Johnston, W.F., (1971). Broadcast burning slash favors black spruce reproduction on organic soil in Minnesota. Forestry Chronicle 47, 1 33–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Kilgore, B.M., (1972). Impact of prescribed burning on a sequoia-mixed conifer forest. Proc. Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference 345–375.Google Scholar

Kilgore, B.M., Briggs, G.S., (1972). Restoring fire to high elevation forests in California. Journal of Forestry 70, 5 226–271.Google Scholar

Komarek, E.V. Sr., (1964). The natural history of lightning. Proc. Third Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Tallahassee, Florida, 139–180.Google Scholar

Krebs, C.J., (1972). Ecology: The experimental analysis of distribution and abundance. Harper and Row New York 694.Google Scholar

Krefting, L.W., (1951). What is the future of the Isle Royale moose herd? Trans. North American Wildlife Conference 16, 461–470.Google Scholar

Küchler, A.W., (1964). Potential natural vegetation of the conterminous United States. American Geographical Society, Special Publ. 36 116map (in color) and manual.Google Scholar

Lebarron, R.K., (1939). The role of forest fires in the reproduction of black spruce. Proceedings of the Minnesota Academy of Science 7, 10–14.Google Scholar

Lebarron, R.K., Eyre, F.H., (1939). The release of seeds from jack pine cones. Journal of Forestry 37, 305–309.Google Scholar

Leopold, A., (1921). The wilderness and its place in forest recreational policy. Journal of Forestry 19, 718–721.Google Scholar

Littlejohn, B.M., Pimlott, D.H., (1971). Why wilderness?. New Press Toronto, Ontario.Google Scholar

Loucks, O.L., (1970). Evolution of diversity, efficiency, and community stability. American Zoologist 10, 17–25.CrossRefGoogle ScholarPubMed

Mac Arthur, R.H., (1958). Population ecology of some warblers of northeastern coniferous forests. Ecology 39, 599–619.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Marschner, F.J., (1930). Original forests of Minnesota. A map compiled from General Land Office survey notes, on file in the U.S. Dept. Agriculture, Washington, D.C., and North Central Forest Experiment Station, St. Paul, Minnesota. 45 × 53 in., in color, unpublished.Google Scholar

Maissurow, D.K., (1935). Fire as a necessary factor in the perpetuation of white pine. Journal of Forestry 33, 373–378.Google Scholar

Martin, P.S., (1973). The discovery of America. Science 179, 969–974.Google Scholar

Martin, R.J., (1934a). Climatic summary of the United States, Section 46—Southeastern Minnesota. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Weather Bureau 26.Google Scholar

Martin, R.J., (1934b). Climatic summary of the United States, Section 44—Northern Minnesota. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture, Weather Bureau 27.Google Scholar

Maycock, P.F., Curtis, J.T., (1960). The phytosociology of boreal conifer-hardwood forests of the Great Lakes region. Ecological Monographs 30, 1 1–35.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Mech, L.D., (1970). The Wolf: The Ecology and Behavior of an Endangered Species. American Museum of Natural History, Natural History Press Garden City, New York.Google Scholar

Mech, L. D., Wolf numbers in the Superior National Forest in Minnesota. In press. U.S. Forest Service, Research Paper.Google Scholar

Mech, L.D., Frenzel, L.D. Jr., (1971). Ecological studies of the timber wolf in northeastern Minnesota. U.S. Forest Service Research Paper NC-52 62.Google Scholar

Mirov, N.T., (1967). The Genus Pinus. Ronald Press New York.Google Scholar

Nute, G.L., (1945). The Voyageur's Highway. Minnesota Historical Society St. Paul, Minnesota.Google Scholar

Ohmann, L.F., Ream, R.R., (1971a). Wilderness ecology: a method of sampling and summarizing data for plant community classification. U.S. Forest Service Research Paper NC-49 14.Google Scholar

Ohmann, L.F., Ream, R.R., (1971b). Wilderness ecology: virgin plant communities of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area. U.S. Forest Service Research Paper NC-63 55.Google Scholar

Peek, J.M., (1972). Adaptations to the burn: moose and deer studies. Naturalist (Journal Natural History Society of Minnesota) 23, 3,4 8–14.Google Scholar

Roe, E.I., (1963). Seed stored in cones of some jack pine stands, northern Minnesota. U.S. Forest Service Research Paper LS-1 14.Google Scholar

Rosendahl, C.O., (1948). A contribution to the knowledge of the Pleistocene flora of Minnesota. Ecology 29, 284–315.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Rowe, J.S., (1959). Forest regions of Canada. Canada Dept. of Northern Affairs and Natural Resources, Forestry Branch, Bull. 123 71.Google Scholar

Sando, R.W., (1969). Prescribed burning weather in Minnesota. U.S. Forest Service Research Paper NC-28 8.Google Scholar

Sando, R.W., Haines, D.A., (1972). Fire weather and behavior of the Little Sioux fire. North Central Forest. U. S. Forest Service Research Paper NC-76 6.Google Scholar

Sando, R.W., Wick, C.H., (1972). A method of evaluating crown fuels in forest stands. North Central Forest. U.S. Forest Service Research Paper NC-84 10.Google Scholar

Scotter, G.W., (1971). Wildfires in relation to the habitat of barren-ground caribou in the taiga of northern Canda. Proc. Tenth Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Fredericton, N.B., 85–105.Google Scholar

Sims, P.K., (1970). Geologic map of Minnesota. Bedrock geology. Minnesota Geological SurveyMisc. map series, Map M-14.Google Scholar

Spurr, S.H., (1954). The forests of Itasca in the nineteenth century as related to fire. Ecology 35, 21–25.Google Scholar

Svoboda, F.J., Gullion, G.W., (1972). Preferential use of aspen by ruffed grouse in northern Minnesota. Journal of Wildlife Management 36, 4 1166–1180.Google Scholar

Swain, A.M., (1972). A fire history of the Boundary Waters Canoe Area as recorded in lake sediment. Naturalist (Journal Natural History Society of Minnesota) 23, 3,4 24–31.Google Scholar

U.S. Dept. of Agriculture(1941). Climate and Man. U.S. Dept. of Agriculture Yearbook 12481941.Google Scholar

Van Raalte, G.D., (1972). Do I have a budworm-susceptible forest?. Forestry Chronicle 48, 190–192.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Van Wagner, C.E., (1966). Three experimental fires in jack pine slash. Canada Department of Forestry, Publ. 1146 22.Google Scholar

Van Wagner, C.E., (1971). Fire and red pine. Proc. Tenth Annual Tall Timbers Fire Ecology Conference Fredericton, N.B., 211–219.Google Scholar

Vogl, R.J., Beck, A.M., (1970). Response of white-tailed deer to a Wisconsin wildfire. American Midland Naturalist 84, 269–272.Google Scholar

Whittaker, R.H., (1970). Communities and Ecosystems. Macmillan New York.Google Scholar

Wright, H.E. Jr., (1968). The roles of pine and spruce in the forest history of Minnesota and adjacent areas. Ecology 49, 937–955.Google Scholar

Wright, H.E. Jr., (1971). Retreat of the Laurentide Ice Sheet from 14,000 to 9,000 years ago. Quarternary Research 1, 316–330.CrossRefGoogle Scholar

Wright, H.E. Jr., Watts, W.A., (1969). Glacial and vegetational history of northeastern Minnesota. Minnesota Geological Survey, Special Publication Series SP-11 59.Google Scholar

Yeatman, C.W., (1967). Biogeography of jack pine. Canadian Journal of Botany 45, 2201–2211.CrossRefGoogle Scholar