Actor Swap - TV Tropes

There are three main reasons why a show or film might end up having multiple actors play the same role. All these methods dovetail neatly with the Literary Agent Hypothesis, the conceit that to the characters, nothing has changed, because the actors are merely playing roles in stories that "actually happened."

1. The original actor might have left, due to injury, contract dispute, illness, or even death. The most common way to handle this is to dispose of the old character in some way, and add a replacement. However, if the producers choose to not write out the original character, they will need to do an actor swap. Three ways to do this are:
   • Fake Shemp: Hide it by minimizing the audience's view of the substitute.
   • The Nth Doctor: Explain it on-screen, using Applied Phlebotinum or Magic Plastic Surgery.
   • The Other Darrin: Just do it with no In-Universe explanation.
2. In some cases, an actor may be replaced in the middle of production. Obviously, it would be too confusing to have the same character be played by two different people in the same film/episode. That is, unless your name is Ed Wood. Therefore, this can only be handled by:
   • The Other Marty: Reshoot everything with the replacement.
3. Alternately, the character might need to be aged, or made younger, beyond the capacity of cosmetics to do convincingly. Again, an actor swap is needed. Two common examples are:
   • Time-Shifted Actor: When the show has hefty time compression, squeezing decades into hours.
   • Soap Opera Rapid Aging Syndrome: The show is in real time, but the character ages unnaturally fast.
4. The fourth reason of three is double casting, where multiple actors share a role in a stage play, each taking it on different nights. In the West, this is mostly only done with children, due to the acting time limits for kid actors, but in Japan and Korea, it's quite common across all roles.

---

Tropes:

Fan Works

• Portal 2: The (Unauthorized) Musical: Patrice Bowler and Erin Mudry play Chell in the same show so the character can leap through one portal and instantly emerge from the other. They also sing a duet together at one point.
• Twilight the Musical: There are two girls cast in the part of Isabella Swan. The creators have said this is to emphasize Bella's vague personality— she's such a flat character, she might as well be anyone.

Theatre

• 2:22: A Ghost Story: Nearly every production, excluding the 2024 UK Tour, has different actors, ranging from Lily Allen to Tom Felton.
• Mozart L'Opera Rock: In the 2013 Japanese production featured Akinori Nakagawa and Koji Yamamoto alternating the roles of Mozart and Salieri.

Web Video

• Heroes & Halfwits: Orma has now been played by eight people owing to her Extreme Omnivore and Can't Hold Her Liquor habits leading her to fall unconscious. Apparently she was a character devised to be played like this too.

---