BelGeddes
- ️David Dodge
A Fine Road Not Taken
Norman Bel Geddes was an
industrial designer who flourished between the wars. He is
well known for his theater
designs and his handsome and collectable cocktail shakers,
cook stoves, radios, Deco window displays, butcher scales, &c.
....But my favorites are the great visionary projects - the teardrop double
decker bus, the tear drop car, the streamlined railroad train, , the factory
for Toledo Scale Co, the restaurants, one on a tower, one in a dam,
the streamlined ship the floating dance palace, the model of the
city of the future in the GM exhibit of the 1940 New York World's Fair.
a number of swoopy theaters, the floating airport at the tip of Manhattan.
When I was a child I found a copy of his wonderful book, Horizons,
in my parents library. I would stare at this great stuff for hours.
It is still one of my favorite possessions.
In 1929 he proposed the Airliner Number 4 as the transatlantic
airliner of 1940. It occupied a chapter of Horizons..
Bel Geddes was much impressed by the Dornier DO-X and was convinced that size was the key to safety and steamshiplike comfort.
He designed it with the help of Doctor O.A. Koller who, I read, "was responsible for the design of over two hundred different airplanes, including the famous Phalz plane used so extensively by Germany during WWI.......without exception all his planes have flown successfully ."
If anyone knows more about Dr. Koller, please enlighten me.

SOME STATS
Bel Geddes Airliner
#4
(1929) |
Boeing 747- 400
(1988) |
|
Passengers | sleeps 606 | 600 trying to sleep |
Crew | 155 | 16 |
Wing Span | 528' | 211' 5" |
Total power | 38,000 hp | thrust = 260kn appr |
Engines | 20 1,900 hp internal
combustion engines |
4 PW4056 Turbo fans |
Engines in reserve | 6 1,900 hp internal
combustion engines |
none |
Maximum Speed | 150 mph | mach 0.92 |
Cruising Speed | 100 mph | ??? |
Landing Speed | 72 mph | ??? |
Absolute Ceiling | 10,000 ft | 45,000ft |
Time to Climb to ceiling | 1 hr | ??? |
Speed at Ceiling | 87-1/2 mph | ??? |
Cruising Range Without
Refueling |
7,500 miles | 7,520 miles |
Gross Weight | 1,275,300 lbs | 870,000 lbs |
Unloaded Weight | 662,600 lbs | 736,761 lbs |
Load | 612,700 lbs | 131,239 lbs |
Time from Chicago to
Plymouth England |
42 hrs | ??? |
Cost of trip | $300 -1930's money | Price depends on many variables |
Cost of aircraft | $9,000,000 - 1930's money | $130,000,000 in 1992 |
COMFORT
Bel Geddes Airliner #4 (1929) | Boeing 747-400 (1988) |
Main Lounge 36 ft high
9 decks 3 Kitchens 13 pantries Library writing rooms 2 public dining rooms The main dining room coverts into a dance floor for 100 couples orchestra platform 3 private dining rooms capable of feeding 40 people 4 deck tennis courts 6 shuffle board courts 6 quoits pitches library writing room 1 gym with dressing rooms and showers 1 men's Solarium w/16 couches and a masseur 1 womens Solarium w/16 couches and a masseuse 1 childrens playroom 1 doctors office with waiting room Barber shop hairdressers salon 2 bars 1 store 1 huge promenade deck 1 Veranda Cafe seats 90 18 single state rooms 81 double staterooms 24 suites w/ baths 179 sleeping rooms Air-conditioning |
2 decks
Bar cart Peanuts 606 seats w/ fold-down tables - 32" pitch Air-conditioning |
THE CREW
1 Captain
1 Mate
2 Navigators
2 Pilots
1 Chief Engineer
2 Engineers
7 Mechanics
2 Radio Operators
2 Electricians
4 Seamen
1 Purser
1 Cashier
2 Telephone
Operators
2 Clerks
1 Stenographer
1 Librarian
1 Baggage Master
2 Baggage Men
1 Chief Steward
1 Chief Dining-
Room Steward
2 Head Waiters
2 Wine Stewards
24 Waiters
7 Bus Boys
1 Chief Bar Steward
9 Bar Stewards
1 Chief Deck Steward
6 Deck Stewards
1 Chef, 6 Cooks,
2 Dishwashers, 24 Room
Stewards, 16 Room Stewardesses. 1 Doctor , 1 Nurse, 1 Gymnast, 1
Masseur, 1 Masseuse, 1 Barber, 1 Hairdresser, 1 Manicurist, 7 Musicians,
I Shop Attendant, 1 Children's Room Stewardess
SAFETY
"The interior of the auxiliary
wing contains a thoroughly equipped engine room, with machine and repair
shops, and carries six motors in reserve." There
is a small railroad so the engines can be changed in flight,
and moved around at ease within the auxiliary wing. The nonfunctioning
motor can be replaced with a reserve motor within five minutes and broken
motor run over to the machine shop and to be repaired on the spot.
Bel Geddes figured that while it required 20 engines to lift the ship off the water, only 12 were needed to fly at cruising speed, so it would be possible to remain in the air on just half the engines with which it was equipped. He considered this a safety factor of 2.
The pontoons carried 6 completely enclosed 40 ft lifeboats capable of carrying 110 people apiece. They were to have engines, windows along the side, radio gear, and food and water for 2 weeks..
If this didn't prove adequate, the Airliner carried two small seaplanes with folding wings. These, could be launched in the air or on the water. They were to get help in an emergency.
MONEY
Bel Geddes worked it all out and I can do no better than to quote from the book.
"Originally, certain Chicago
business men were interested in the possibility of constructing this
plane with the idea of operating it between Chicago and London via the
St. Lawrence River and Great Circle Route. Careful figures based on a detailed
study of all factors involved indicate that the venture is practicable
from a commercial viewpoint. The flying time of this plane between Chicago
and Plymouth is forty-two hours. She is refueled in flight while passing
over Newfoundland. She is able to make three crossings a week, due allowance
being made for overhauling in port. This Is a great advantage in competition
with ocean liners, the fastest of which can make only one crossing a week.
The cost of building, equipping and furnishing a modern ocean liner approximates
$60,000,000. Air Liner Number 4 can be built, equipped, and furnished for
approximately $9,000,000. Assume that after the air liner has made half
a dozen successful round trips on schedule, she will thereafter be filled
to capacity. Further, assume that the
price
per passenger will be the same as an average first-class steamship passage,
say $300. Furthermore, realize that the accommodations of this air liner
are equal in spaciousness and comfort to the most modern ocean liner. The
revenue per trip from fares will then be $135,300 and for the three trips
a week, $405,000. Mail $48,000 and baggage $17,000, giving a weekly gross
revenue of $470,900. The cost of crewwages for the week will approximate
$8,000; fuel and maintenance $121,500; supplies, food and other items,
$10,000. Insurance, office rent, salaries and overhead $76,750; depreciation
on plane based on only a three-year life, $57,700; which totals a weekly
operating expense of $273,950. This shows a net weekly revenue of $196,950.
The plane, therefore, returns 10 percent on the investment and amortizes
its cost in approximately three years, whereas, owing to greater original
cost and higher operating expense, the modern ocean liner cannot pay for
herself in many, many times this period."
I think there must have been something to the Chicago business men. I don't think he had given up by the time he wrote the book in 1932. He closes the chapter by remarking that....
"Chicago, for instance,
under influences that will arise concomitantly with intercontinental aviation,
may easily become as much a world metropolis as New York"
...& NOW?
This isn't as daffy as it seems to us as we hustle about on the verge of the third millennium. The Airliner #4 was proposed in 1929 to be flying in 1940. And sure enough by 1940 Transatlantic airliners were large luxurious flying boats.
So lets not loose heart. It sure would make a swell cruise ship for carting the folks around the Caribbean. Heck I'd pay my $10 for the movie - lots of Ritzy Retro night life, neato special effects for the desperate launching of the the two small planes to warn the world that Nazis had kidnapped everyone....
I've been toying with the idea of a model with 10 tiny electric motors, each carrying two propellers, one on each end. It seems a natural for foam. Of course the radio guys could do a complete interior complete with a working orchestra that you could view through the windows.
For some awe inspiring
renderings of the Airliner #4 cruising over a fantastic city by Andy
Lacow, an interesting artist with a taste for such good things. Click
the clicker.
ANDY
LACKOW (CLICK)
I love this thing and if
anyone knows more please write me.
dannysoar@worldnet.att.net
All the quoted text and all the pix
except the photo of the model come from Bel Geddes' book Horizons.I
found the photo in Yesterday's Tomorrows, a book full of hormone
tickling "future stuff" by Joseph Corn and Brian Horrigan. The pic seems
to have originated at Stanford.
HOME (CLICK)