nytimes.com

We Helped Scientists Track Birds This Summer. (Published 2023)

  • ️Thu May 18 2023
A small, round bird with a yellow stripe above its eye, perched on brown marsh grasses in the bright sun.
The saltmarsh sparrow, one of many bird species threatened by sea level rise. Credit...Raymond Hennessy/Alamy

One Saturday morning in June, Amy Simmons spotted some sparrows flitting around a coastal marsh in Maine. She and her two companions, all dedicated bird-watchers, quickly identified one of the foraging birds as a Nelson’s sparrow, a small, round bird with a yellow stripe over its eye. Then, overhead, they spotted something slightly different. The stripe over this sparrow’s eye had a more saturated, orange tint, and its breast was speckled with black and white.

It was a saltmarsh sparrow, a species threatened by sea level rise. Without significant conservation action, climate change could render the species extinct by the middle of this century, some scientists predict.

“It’s a beautiful bird,” said Ms. Simmons, who works in fund-raising at the National Audubon Society. “It’s exciting to see it. But then it kind of breaks your heart at the same time. Because it is so threatened right now.”

Ms. Simmons snapped some photos and logged the observation in eBird, a website and app that allows scientists at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology to collect observations from bird-watchers worldwide. The data has already helped scientists keep tabs on bird populations, many of which are in steep decline, and track how their behaviors and lives are shifting with a changing climate.

But the data has gaps; eBird generally receives fewer submissions in the summer than it does during the spring and fall migratory seasons, and much of the data comes from popular bird-watching locations, like parks and nature preserves. So this summer, The New York Times collaborated with the lab on a citizen science project, inviting readers to make birding part of their daily routines and to share their observations with researchers. Participants were encouraged to continue birding throughout the slow season and to venture beyond their favorite bird-watching haunts.

We shared a video showcasing participants, and how the data you submitted helps scientific research, with attendees of the The New York Times Climate Forward event, a gathering of leaders in business, science and public policy about the solutions to climate change.

Illustration of the silhouettes of five birds with a purple backdrop
Credit...Simone Noronha

America’s birds are in trouble. Since 1970, nearly 3 billion birds have vanished from the skies over North America.

Most of those losses have been in migratory species, which may breed in the United States or Canada in the summer before heading elsewhere for the winter. Many spend more time living on Caribbean beaches or in Costa Rican forests than they do in American backyards. “They’re really visitors to North America,” said Viviana Ruiz-Gutierrez, co-director of the Center for Avian Population Studies at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology.

Protecting these birds will require working across international borders and safeguarding all of their habitats, many of which are under threat. If migrating birds lose their winter refuges, the consequences will ripple across the hemisphere.

“If we lose Central America’s forests, we can lose North America’s birds,” said Jeremy Radachowsky, the director for Mesoamerica and the western Caribbean at the Wildlife Conservation Society.

To illuminate these connections, scientists at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology developed “shared stewardship” maps in collaboration with Partners in Flight, an international bird conservation network. Each map displays the key wintering grounds for the migratory species that have a significant summer presence in a particular U.S. state or region. The maps are based on data from eBird, a database of observations from bird watchers around the world.

Eiders are among the birds that frequently show up in puzzles. Credit...Olaf Oliviero Riemer, via commons.wikimedia.org

As our thanks for contributing to the Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s important work, we are inviting readers to spot the many feathered friends that have appeared in the New York Times Crossword.

The good news is that these birds can be found without binoculars: All you need is a pencil if you want to print the puzzles out, or a device on which to solve them. And if you’d like a guide, the Wordplay crossword column provides hints and tips. (Fair warning: The columns contain spoilers for the puzzles.)

Birding Adventure No. 1 (Puzzle, Wordplay column)

Those chevron-shaped black squares in this puzzle make spotting the birds easy: They are supposed to resemble a flock of birds in flight. All you have to do is decipher the message that runs through the long Across entries.

Birding Adventure No. 2 (Puzzle, Wordplay column)

You may need to really search for the birds in this crossword. We’d point them out to you, but the fun is in the finding.

Birding Adventure No. 3 (Puzzle, Wordplay column)

Interesting looking grid, isn’t it? It’s definitely a bird, but what kind? See if you can find the game within the game.

Birding Adventure No. 4 (Puzzle, Wordplay column)

Sunday puzzles come with titles, and this one is called “Chick Lit.”

The silhouette of a raptor, sitting atop field lights, appears against a dull red sun in a brown sky.
An osprey rested on field lights in Bremerton, Wash., during wildfires in 2018.Credit...Larry Steagall/Kitsap Sun, via Associated Press

The Maui wildfires are an ongoing human tragedy. At least 111 people have died, more than 1,000 people are unaccounted for, and many have been displaced from their homes.

But such fires also put animals at risk. Wildlife, livestock and pets often perish in fires. Flames can destroy critical habitats for endangered species and set back conservation efforts. (The Hawaii fires threatened the Maui Bird Conservation Center, which is home to some of the world’s most endangered birds.) And all creatures that breathe air are susceptible to smoke.

“Birds are especially vulnerable, because they have an incredibly efficient respiratory system, which is designed to deliver enough oxygen to power flight,” said Olivia Sanderfoot, an ecologist at the University of California, Los Angeles, who studies how smoke affects birds and other wildlife. The avian respiratory system is especially adept at drawing oxygen out of the air, but if there are pollutants wafting around, birds take those up readily, too.

Precisely how smoke affects birds is still a nascent field of research, with many unanswered questions. But studies have shown that smoke can damage birds’ lungs and make them more vulnerable to respiratory infections. And the fine particulate matter that is present in smoke — and causes well-documented health problems in humans — can also accumulate in birds’ airways. “We know that air pollution, and smoke specifically, causes respiratory distress and makes it more difficult for birds to breathe,” Dr. Sanderfoot said.

Plumes of smoke may also disrupt the journeys of migrating birds, many of which are under threat. In 2020, tule geese, which summer in Alaska, began their fall migrations in the middle of a record wildfire season on the West Coast. The geese needed more than double the usual time to arrive at their traditional Oregon stopover site, and their flight paths were nearly 500 miles longer, scientists found.

Image

Smoke rose from Lahaina on the Hawaii island of Maui the morning after wildfires swept through.Credit...Richard Olsten/Air Maui Helicopters, via Reuters

“We’re beginning to see that birds have to make hard choices when they come across thick smoke,” said Andrew Stillman, an ecologist at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology who studies how major fires affect birds.

Birds can sit and wait for the smoke to clear, which can leave them stranded for days in unfamiliar territory and delay their migration. They can fly around the smoke, making detours that extend their journeys and use up precious energy reserves. Or they can continue to fly through, gulping down smoke as they go. “Either way, the migrating birds are worse off when they finally arrive,” Dr. Stillman said. “And not everybody survives that perilous journey.”

Dr. Sanderfoot is exploring how smoke alters bird behavior and how those responses vary according to species and circumstance. (Some birds of prey seem to be attracted to fires, perhaps because fleeing or injured small animals make for an easy dinner.) Which species are most vulnerable to wildfires? Do birds with larger home ranges find escape easier than do those with smaller territories? Do birds that live in fire-prone areas respond differently than those inhabiting places where wildfires are a newer threat? Do responses vary at different times of year?

“And all of this work is geared toward answering questions that I hear over and over from birders in our community,” Dr. Sanderfoot said. “Folks want to know what’s happening to birds when it’s smoky.”

She is also enlisting amateur bird watchers to help her answer these questions. One new effort, called Project Phoenix, is now seeking California residents who are willing to spend 10 minutes a week observing their local birds through the fire season. Dr. Sanderfoot hopes to learn how birds alter their habitat use in response to smoke, and whether providing bird feeders and baths “could help them thrive as smoke persists on the landscape,” she said. “I’m hoping to put that all together and really help us learn, from a policy standpoint, what we can do to help birds as we see more and more smoke.”

A birder named Patrick Maurice standing in a road with binoculars around his neck and a camera in his hand. He is wearing a baseball cap with a bird on the front.
Patrick Maurice, 24, a birder who lives in Athens, Ga.Credit...Patrick Maurice

We’re featuring profiles of project participants. If you want to share your birding journey and be considered for a profile, please email birds@nytimes.com.

Patrick Maurice credits his mother for his birding passion. One of his earliest memories is of her lifting him up to a scope at age 5 to see a yellow-billed loon near his hometown, Atlanta. His brother also came along on such trips, but only Mr. Maurice became interested enough to become a birder. Now 24, he is trying to make birding a career, as a freelance tour guide around the country.

“Birding is not exactly a popular hobby for a young person,” Mr. Maurice said. “In high school, I kept it in the closet. I had friends, but I didn’t tell them I was a birder.”

He had stopped hiding his passion by the time he went to the University of Georgia, where he pursued a major in wildlife sciences and began thinking about birding for a living. He didn’t want to be a scientist, but he loved showing people birds. His mother encouraged him to find a well-paying job and leave birding for the weekend, as she had. “But I told her that saying, about doing what you love and it won’t feel like work,” Mr. Maurice said.

He has now worked as a junior instructor at several youth birding camps and as an interpretive naturalist for the Cape May Bird Observatory in New Jersey. This summer, he led tours in Yellowstone National Park for Natural Habitat Adventures, a wildlife company. The frequent travel makes it difficult to settle down with a girlfriend, he said, but he summed up his feeling with a German word, zugunruhe, a birding term that describes the restlessness that prompts birds to migrate. “I’m always thinking about the next trip,” he said.

Jim Colgan

An adult penguin shields a baby chick in the foreground with many bigger penguins behind them.
Emperor penguins brooding on Snow Hill Island in Antarctica.Credit...Danita Delimont/Alamy

Four out of five emperor penguin colonies in Antarctica’s Bellingshausen Sea region very likely lost their chicks late last year because of disappearing sea ice underneath their breeding grounds, according to a new study.

Parts of this coastal region had lost all of their sea ice by November, which was probably before penguin chicks had grown waterproof adult feathers and learned to swim. It’s the first time scientists have seen a widespread failure across multiple penguin colonies in a region, researchers said.

“At the moment, we’re not sure if this is just a blip,” said Norman Ratcliffe, a seabird ecologist with the British Antarctic Survey and one of the authors of the new study. “But if this becomes a consistent phenomena in the longer term, clearly it’s going to have repercussions for the species.”

Delger Erdenesanaa

Image

Nadeem Perera, 29, left, and Ollie Olanipekun, 38, are the founders of the birding group Flock Together.Credit...Dhamirah Coombes, via Flock Together

This week’s challenge for new birders: Try joining a group for an outing, or go birding with at least one new person.

And if you’re already part of a birding community, tell us about it. Did you meet friends — or even your spouse — through birding? What does it bring you? In a future dispatch, we’ll share highlights from participants.

In early 2020, as Black Lives Matter protests were taking place worldwide and the pandemic was beginning to unfold, Ollie Olanipekun and Nadeem Perera founded Flock Together, a group for birders of color in Britain.

“I go to these remote towns where there’s no people of color, there’s no diversity,” Mr. Olanipekun, 38, said. “On your own, those looks you’re getting feel like daggers.” Numbers provided a sense of safety.

Since then, Flock Together has expanded its range, organizing walks in New York and Toronto; the group is most active in London and Tokyo. Thousands of people around the world have now connected with Flock Together. Midway through a typical walk, participants sometimes share poetry or other reflections. “It’s the perfect balance of nature nerds and creative heads,” Mr. Perera said.

In 2020, Hannah Kirshenbaum, 26, helped found a Brooklyn-based group called NYC Queer Birders, principally for L.G.B.T.Q. bird enthusiasts. This was just before the pandemic struck; Ms. Kirshenbaum had developed an interest in birding but as a queer person did not always feel at home with traditional birding groups. “We didn’t really see our specific demographic there,” they said.

The group has grown in popularity; its walks, initially attended by only a couple of people, now regularly attract 50 to 100. The draw is social as well as to nature. “We hope that people make friends — or lovers,” Ms. Kirshenbaum said.

Here are some tips to finding a group that’s right for you. Start close to home: Check the schedule at nearby parks or nature reserves, where events might already be taking place, Mr. Olanipekun said. “Lots of people don’t understand the incredible programming that takes place in local parks,” he said.

As part of The Times’s summer birding project, BirdLife International and some Audubon Society chapters have organized special outings from July 28 to 30. See below for more details.

Mr. Olanipekun said that aspiring birders should not let a lack of knowledge hold them back. “The barrier to entry for the activity of bird-watching is super, super, super low,” he said.

Ms. Kirshenbaum recommended poking around on social media for events. “I would just type in ‘queer birding’ on Instagram, and I bet your city has something,” they said. “And if not, you should start it.”

  • New York City: BirdLife International has organized a bird outing in Manhattan at 8 a.m. July 28. Meet at the entrance to Morningside Park at 110th Street and Manhattan Avenue.

  • Northern California: The Golden Gate Audubon Society has organized outings in the San Francisco Bay Area the weekend of July 28. Find out more on the organization’s field trips page.

  • International: BirdLife International has organized bird outings in Singapore and Nairobi. The organization is also planning outings in Bengaluru, India; Brussels; London; and Quito, Ecuador, in the coming weeks. See the group’s event page for more details.

    You can also explore the National Audubon Society’s site to find meet-ups in your location. And the American Birding Association has a list of birding organizations in all 50 states and three Canadian provinces.

    If you go on any of these group outings or an outing in your location, please report back to us on the experience by emailing birds@nytimes.com. We may publish your report in a future update.

Credit...Maxine Hicks for The New York Times

Whether or not you’re into birds, joining a birding group can change your life.

Last week, we looked at groups that birders can join to make the activity a community affair. Our challenge for beginners was to try bird-watching with at least one other person. We also asked if anyone had met friends — or even a spouse — through a birding activity. We didn’t expect so many answers in the affirmative.

“I’m not sure it was our very first date, as she claims,” Rick Wright from Bloomfield, N.J., said. “But it was very early on that I invited a woman to go to the swine effluent ponds with me to look for shorebirds. She said yes. We’ve been married 25 years.”

For Gordon Dayton in Connecticut, it was the reverse. He was not interested in birding when he met his wife of many years, but the activity was something that happened along the way. “Some of us come to birding through love of birds, some through love of bird-lovers,” Mr. Dayton said.

Not everyone is eager to make birding anything more than a solitary activity. “I’m not a joiner,” Margaret Poethig from Arlington, Va., said. But as a beginner, she knew that other birders could help improve her skills. “So I started by participating in a local citizen science project, joined a couple of local bird clubs, went on a few bird walks and volunteered at a couple of club events.” Now she sometimes meets people who post checklists on her local eBird hot spot.

Age differences can also be a factor. When Roberta from Northampton, Va., became a member of her local ornithological society at 22, almost everyone was “middle-aged to ancient,” she said — but the younger people became lifelong friends.

Susana MacLean from Westfield, N.J., recommended that parents look into Young Birder Clubs at their local Audubon Society chapters. When her son was 10, he complained that he couldn’t find birders his own age. She heard about the clubs from the radio program “Science Friday” and said that the experience changed her son’s life: “My son made friends there, and to this day, in his 20s, he gets together with another former N.J. Young Birder to go birding.”

Whether project participants were looking for friends, partners or a sense of community, one consistent theme throughout the comments is that joining other birders is a sure way to improve identification skills, beyond what any guidebook or online resource teaches.

Julie Frost from Rochester Hills, Mich., had a different take on birding groups: “I’m on the trail, a couple of cameras around my neck, almost every day, but I’m rarely with a friend.” Nonetheless, she said, she still feels part of a group: “Others, out for a walk, stop to ask what I see and then share their stories of backyard birding. There’s always a birding community, even if we only know each other on the trails.”

  • A quick reminder that we encourage you to find a bird outing this weekend and report back on your experience. Here are some ways to get started.

  • More than 24,000 have signed up, and we’ve had almost 360,000 observations. Don’t forget to add #NYT to your eBird checklists. Make sure you’re counted. Contribute to the science project by signing up here.

Throughout the summer birding project, we have been encouraging new birders to try different ways to observe birds. Sketching is one way to deepen your observation skills.

We asked a master illustrator, David Sibley, to share tips on how to draw, and we invited readers to share their attempts. Below is a selection of what you sent us, along with insights into how it changed your birding experience.

Tell us in the comments: Have you tried sketching? Has it changed the way you observe birds?

Credit...Jia-En Ho

“Drawing birds has given me a new perspective on birdwatching, allowing me to slow down and appreciate their features through each brushstroke.”

Jia-En Ho, 21, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia

Credit...Cassandra Myer

“When you are up close and personal, you see common details that lead to a better understanding of bird physiology, plus barn owls have the sweetest faces.”

Cassandra Myer, 70, Viera, Fla.

Credit...Josiah Haley

“Drawing birds makes me look at them more closely and find all the details. It helps me like them even more.”

Josiah Haley, 9, Lock Haven, Pa.

Credit...Jared Nielsen

“I find observing birds changes how I draw them. Rather than attempt photorealism, I sketch as quickly as possible to capture the birdiness of my subject.”

Jared Nielsen, 44, Baltimore, Md.

Credit...Margaret Dimon

“This started as a drawing and became a collage which I’ve just completed. It’s a mockingbird, and some of the pieces of paper are piano sheet music.”

Margaret Dimon, 70, Naples, Fla.

Credit...Marisol Dominguez

“Drawing birds has changed the way I observe them. I now see more details about their features that I would regularly ignore. I see how delicate their beaks and feathers are through drawing since these are typically translucent.”

Marisol Dominguez, 29, El Paso, Texas

Credit...Mari Kamidoi

“My favorite color is brown, and I am very fond of birds that many people may overlook just due to their ‘boring’ coloration. I think that the different shades of brown that the ovenbird has, as well as its spots, are very beautiful.”

Mari Kamidoi, 20, Ann Arbor, Mich.

Credit...Ryan Spaulding

“I’m inspired by the Western kingbird. They are also one of the earliest morning singers around, making these funny noises that sound as if a marching band conductor is warming up. While that might sound obnoxious to some, I find it to be comforting against the quiet desert morning.”

Ryan Spaulding, 38, Bishop, Calif.

Credit...Paula Heaphy

“During lockdown I heard a cooing outside my window every morning. An owl or a pigeon? It was the one sound that soothed me over the sirens. I often find the little visitor peeking in my window or hanging out on my fire escape.”

Paula Heaphy, 51, Brooklyn

Credit...Dean Cole

“I found this poor bird lying on the sidewalk in front of my house. She was quite dead but for no apparent reason. There was no sign of feline-induced trauma, and nothing appeared broken.”

Dean Cole, 66, Bloomfield, N.J.

Credit...Isadora Davis

“I'm sending my drawing of a kingfisher (based on a photograph), which I drew a couple months ago for a class at the Art and Design High School in Manhattan.”

Isadora Davis, 17, Brooklyn, NY

Credit...Roi Amaru García Ruiz

“I am absolutely passionate about birds. It is a pleasure to share some draws with the birding community.”

Roi Amaru García Ruiz, 10, Foz Bay, Lugo, Spain

Credit...Pablo Herráiz Carbonaro

“I am sending you a sketch of a lesser spotted woodpecker (Dendrocopos minor) seen last winter in El Pardo, Madrid.”

Pablo Herráiz Carbonaro, 46, Madrid

Credit...Julie Frost

“My drawing with watercolor markers. A common visitor to my backyard, where they loudly caw each morning if I am late with the daily in-shell peanut allotment.”

Julie Frost, Rochester Hills, Mich.

Credit...Jaki Hurwitz

“Mr. Sibley is correct — after spending two hours trying to reproduce a picture of a Carolina wren, I realized I could close my eyes and picture every marking on that bird. Three days later, I was rewarded by seeing that bird at my feeder and immediately could identify it.”

Jaki Hurwitz, 71, Neavitt, Md.

A bird with a bit of yellow above its beak and brown wings is standing on a piece of wood and singing.
Credit...B. E. Small/blickwinkel, via Alamy

Language has long been considered the exclusive provenance of humans.

But in the animal kingdom, birds, not primates, communicate with the level of vocal complexity and variability closest to ours. Ornithologists have made progress in understanding the rich variety of ways in which birds converse, thanks in part to large and growing databases of bird calls such as one from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, which includes millions of recordings captured by citizen scientists.

Each bird species has its own distinct set of sounds. Consider the black-capped chickadee, which frequents the northern United States and southern Canada year-round.

With only slight variation, black-capped chickadees from Vancouver to Virginia make this same vocalization.

Still more amazing is what birds can express with specific sounds. Test your ability to decipher them.

Elaine Chen

Jason Hall, bearded and wearing a green knit hat with a Patagonia label, peers through a spotting scope. The branches of trees are reflected on its lens.
“Why would you not take the step of being brave and moving forward?” Jason Hall, a birder in Pennsylvania, said.Credit...Kriston Jae Bethel for The New York Times

On the same day George Floyd was murdered by a police officer on a Minneapolis street — Memorial Day, 2020 — Christian Cooper was searching for songbirds in Central Park. Mr. Cooper, who is Black, would be vaulted to fame after a run-in with a white woman who called the police and falsely claimed he was threatening her when he asked her to leash her dog.

To David Yarnold, the chief executive of the National Audubon Society at the time, both events demanded a response. The powerful conservation group and pre-eminent bird enthusiasts’ organization needed to weigh in, and even examine itself.

“Black lives matter,” Mr. Yarnold, who is white, wrote in a letter to the society’s staff after the first weekend of the George Floyd protests. “Our nation is in turmoil because our governments, our institutions (including Audubon), and private individuals haven’t done nearly enough to act on that fundamental truth.”

Mr. Yarnold promised to start a “long conversation” about how the Audubon Society could “become antiracist in everything we do.”

Three years later, that long conversation has led the society into an all-out feud over its own handling of race within the organization. Complaints about workplace conditions and the treatment of minority employees and hobbyists are bound up in the question of whether the conservation group should drop its namesake, John James Audubon, who owned slaves.

Video

CreditCredit...Alamy

Record temperatures, drought, smoky air and loss of habitat make it increasingly difficult for feathered and other winged creatures in urban and suburban areas to find the water they need.

But there’s a simple way that humans can help them out: install a birdbath.

“A source of clean, fresh water can be one of the hardest things for birds to find,” said Kim Eierman, an environmental horticulturist and the founder of EcoBeneficial, an ecological landscape design firm, who teaches at the New York Botanical Garden and Brooklyn Botanic Garden.

Putting in birdbaths is something that’s easy for homeowners and even apartment dwellers and tenants of commercial spaces, she said. “You’re increasing the health of the birds by providing a resource that’s really tough to find,” said Ms. Eierman, who lays out nature-friendly tips in her book “The Pollinator Victory Garden.” “In the summer months, it’s way more important than putting up birdseed.”

A female Northern Cardinal, with dull yellow plumage and a bright red beak, sitting atop a faded picket fence.
A female Northern Cardinal. A study of five prominent natural history museums found that their avian collections skewed heavily toward male specimens. Credit...Julio Cortez/Associated Press

Every Memorial Day weekend since 2020, the five members of the Galbatross Project have hosted Female Bird Day to encourage birders to identify, appreciate and collect data on what they call the “most misunderstood birds in North America.”

“Humans are visual creatures,” said Joanna Wu, a doctoral student in the ecology and evolutionary biology program at the University of California, Los Angeles, and a member of the Galbatross Project. “We are attracted to things that are bright. In North America, that tends to be male birds.”

Half of all birds are females, yet they have long been overlooked in ornithology. A study of five prominent natural history museums, including the American Museum of Natural History in New York and London’s Natural History Museum, found that their avian collections skewed heavily toward male specimens. In a 2018 article Kenn Kaufman, a field editor for Audubon Magazine, wrote that “an unconscious bias against female birds is widespread in birding,” and described his own efforts to correct his partiality.

Scientists are beginning to realize what they’ve been missing. For instance, female birds were long assumed to rarely sing. This notion likely grew out of a longstanding focus on birds of North America, where female birds do tend to sing less than males. But, in the 1990s, researchers turned their attention to the tropics and found that female birds there were prolific singers.

Karan Odom, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Maryland, College Park, is one of the leaders of the Female Bird Song Project, which asks birders to observe and record female birds singing. She has found “evidence that a lot of species have female song and that it is probably more the norm, rather than the exception, and that it’s probably ancestral,” she said.

“Almost every year, I feel like there’s another species or two or three that somebody tells me about with female song,” Dr. Odom said. It helps that ornithology is diversifying, she added, as there is “some evidence that women researchers are more likely to study female bird song.”

The idea for the Galbatross Project took shape in 2019, after a few colleagues at the National Audubon Society participated in the World Series of Birding in New Jersey and decided to count only female birds for their competition list. They finished second to last with just 31 female bird species identified, but they were invigorated by the experience and determined to get other birders to widen their focus.

Their annual Female Bird Day promotes in-person walks and events, but it is primarily an online event built around a hashtag, #FemaleBirdDay, for participants to share photos and facts on social media. Members of the Galbatross Project also give talks at birding organizations explaining why identifying female birds is important and how to do so.

Because male and female birds often have very different domains and behaviors, a better understanding of females can benefit conservation efforts, said Ruth Bennett, an ecologist at the Smithsonian Conservation Biology Institute’s Migratory Bird Center. Dr. Bennett, whose research was one inspiration for the Galbatross Project, made the connection while studying golden-winged warblers, which overwinter in Honduras.

She found that the female warblers were forced out of higher quality habitats by territorial males and congregated in areas disrupted by development. The female warblers suffered habitat loss at twice the rate of their male counterparts, Dr. Bennett and her colleagues found. When they surveyed conservation plans for 66 North American migratory land birds, only 8 percent of the recommendations actually took sexual segregation into account.

Positively identifying females can require a full-fledged bird detective. Some bird species display very clear differences between the sexes — the male cardinal is bright red, while the female is closer to brown — but many others require close attention to things like the color of the bill or how the nest is built. Timing can also be a useful clue for birders: In some migratory species, the female birds migrate later in the spring than the males do.

Ms. Wu encouraged birders to embrace the challenge of identifying female birds. “You get to know the birds so intimately, too,” she said. “You have to know their life cycle, when they reproduce, what they’re up to.”

For developing your female birding skills, Purbita Saha, a member of the project and an editor at Popular Science, recommends starting with just a handful of common nearby species and learning as many details as possible about those females. One resource is the Cornell Lab of Ornithology’s All About Birds website. “If you’re not looking out for female birds, you’re only getting half of the picture,” she said.


A male goldfinch, bright yellow with black wings, and a paler female perch on the stems of purple zinnias.
Goldfinches, a male and a female, enjoying the zinnias in a garden in Illinois.Credit...Richard & Susan Day/Danita Delimont, via Alamy

At the outset of the Times birding project, we asked participants what they most wanted to know about birds. The most common question we received: How do you make a yard appealing to birds?

We invited Kim Eierman, an ecological landscape designer based just outside New York City, to share some tips. Ms. Eierman, the founder of EcoBeneficial, a horticulture consultancy, teaches at the New York Botanical Garden and the Brooklyn Botanic Garden, among other places, and will be leading a discussion on the topic at the Climate Forward event on Sept. 21.

Start with thinking of your landscape as an ecosystem, not just a garden, Ms. Eierman says. In her view, conventional lawns — “green deserts” — and nonnative plant species have no place in that system. Instead, focus on what she calls “the big four for birds”: nesting sites, cover, natural food sources and clean water.

Here’s what Ms. Eierman recommends:

Emulate the layers found in a local, natural ecosystem

Many residents of the Northeast live in what was once a forest ecosystem. The layers of that ecosystem are obvious — canopy trees, sub-canopy trees, shrubs, an herbaceous layer of perennials — and aren’t difficult to recreate.

Plant regional native species that are appropriate for your landscape conditions.

Native plants have evolved in tandem with the wildlife they support. For instance, native plants that produce fruit late in the season tend to have highly nutritious fruit timed for migrating songbirds.

Plant a diverse array of native species.

In the adult stage, birds may be graminivores (seed-eaters), frugivores (fruit-eaters), insectivores (insect-eaters), carnivores (flesh-eaters) or omnivores (mixed diet). And then there are the omni-omnivores like blue jays that would probably eat a hot dog if you offered it to them.

Tolerate some messiness in your landscape

Resist the urge to cut back the dead stems of native flowering perennials and grasses; leave them standing through winter. Consider leaving a dead or dying tree standing in your landscape. Let fallen leaves remain in place; this “leaf litter” is a miniature ecosystem of invertebrates, which are a vital food source for foraging birds.

Change other “cultural” practices in your landscape.

Keep your cats indoors; feline pets and feral cats kill between 1.3 and 4 billion birds each year in the United States. And forego pesticides; instead, plant native plants that attract natural insect predators and parasitoids, like ladybugs, that help keep unwanted pests in check. A truly bird-friendly landscape is pesticide-free.

Share the knowledge.

Enjoy the rewards of making your landscape more bird-friendly, but don’t stop there. Build community and connectivity by sharing the knowledge with neighbors, family, friends and local organizations and municipalities.

Share yours: Have you turned your yard into a bird-friendly garden or replaced your “green desert” with native species? Send a photo to birds@nytimes.com and we might feature it here.

A grid of photos of Ajay Banga, Robin Wall Kimmerer, Marie Kondo, Bill Gates, Michael Bloomberg and Ebony Twilley Martin.
The Times climate event featured interviews and sessions with speakers including (clockwise from upper left) Ajay Banga, Robin Wall Kimmerer, Marie Kondo, Bill Gates, Michael R. Bloomberg and Ebony Twilley Martin.

Climate change is an issue that stretches across borders, touching every facet of our lives. Addressing it likewise requires shifts in almost every industry and institution. On Sept. 21, The New York Times will bring together newsmakers, including innovators, activists, scientists and policymakers, for an all-day event examining the actions needed to confront climate change.

Times subscribers can sign up to watch the livestream and connect with online attendees.

Sessions will include: Ajay Banga, president of the World Bank Group; Al Gore, former vice president of the United States; Bill Gates, founder of Breakthrough Energy and co-chair of the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation; Ebony Twilley Martin, executive director of Greenpeace USA; Marie Kondo, tidying expert and founder of KonMari Media; Michael R. Bloomberg, founder of Bloomberg L.P. and Bloomberg Philanthropies and Robin Wall Kimmerer, scientist and author.

Signing up for the livestream will also give you an opportunity to chat with attendees on the messaging platform Slack, launching a week before the event. Each day will feature a different topic and guests, including about birding and biodiversity.

Details about the Slack channel and event schedule will be shared after registering.

A photo of storm petrel birds at sunset.
Storm petrels near Point Pinos, Calif.Credit...David Ledig/Planetpix, via Alamy

This summer’s weather records — a summer of climate reckoning, in the words of the Times Opinion columnist David Wallace-Wells — have brought a number of challenges for birds. Unprecedented wildfires have burned all summer in Canada, posing a threat to the respiratory systems that power the flights of migratory species. Emperor penguins lost breeding grounds to record-low Antarctic sea ice.

Now it’s hurricane season. Just like wildfires, hurricanes can divert birds from their migratory paths; in the parlance of ornithologists, birds are entrained and displaced by the storms. Essentially, birds that are entrained are pulled into the hurricane, sometimes all the way to its eye; birds that are displaced are pushed away by it.

For birders, this presents an opportunity — birds entrained or pushed off course can make for a rare sighting far inland from normal habitat or migration routes. Hurricane Idalia has been the most significant hurricane of the season so far, briefly reaching Category 4 status before making landfall in rural Florida with a powerful storm surge. And it sent birds in all directions from its path, in a manner that the Cornell Lab of Ornithology has been tracking: American flamingoes on the Outer Banks of North Carolina, black terns in the Atlanta area.

Hurricane Hilary, which resulted in the first tropical storm warning for Los Angeles, scattered birds across the desert. Storm petrels were sighted from Las Vegas to Tucson, Ariz., and another was spotted in the high desert of Nevada toward Reno, near the California border. A red-billed tropic bird, typically found off the coasts of Southern California and Baja California, was seen near Lake Havasu City in Arizona, and frigatebirds clustered near Yuma.

Hurricanes are tough on birds. The Gulf of Mexico, where Idalia pushed through, is one of the hemisphere’s most important migration routes. Entraining and displacing is extra work for birds, and not all survive what is sometimes called a “wreck.” The course and aftermath of a hurricane can be risky for birders, too. But along with the personal reward of spotting an unusual bird, such post-hurricane counts help monitor the health of ecosystems at their extremes.

A mother mourning dove bird sits on her nest that's nestled against a house with one of her two newly hatched baby chicks.
Scientists studying 24 species of birds found that particularly hot or cold snaps could affect the ability of a bird to fledge its nestlings.Credit...Mike Segar/Reuters

Ice storms in Texas, smoke from Canadian wildfires billowing over much of North America, 31 consecutive days of 110-degree heat in Phoenix: Those have been just some of the swings in the weather this year.

How are the birds faring through it all?

It’s too early to draw any confident conclusions from the data, scientists say. Maybe there were fewer sightings of birds in Phoenix during the heat wave, or maybe fewer people ventured outside to bird watch. Based on past data, however, researchers know that hot and cold spells have a negative effect on birds, especially newly born hatchlings. The Cornell Lab of Ornithology runs a program called NestWatch that enables volunteers to report what is going on in a nest: how many eggs, how many of them hatch, how many of the hatchlings eventually fly away.

In a paper that has been submitted to the journal Nature Communications, Conor Taff of the Cornell Lab and J. Ryan Shipley of the Swiss Federal Institute for Forest, Snow and Landscape Research examined more than 300,000 breeding records for 24 North American species of birds from NestWatch and two similar programs, Project NestWatch in Canada and Project MartinWatch, which tracks young purple martins.

For each of the 300,000 nests in North America, Dr. Taff and Dr. Shipley looked up the weather records at that location, noting the hottest and coldest three-day stretches during the nesting period. “When there’s a particularly cold or a particularly hot period, does it impact your ability to successfully fledge nestlings?” Dr. Taff said.

The answer, in many cases, was yes. For 16 of the 24 species, a cold snap significantly reduced the number of hatchlings that made it out of the nest, by about 10 or 20 percent, Dr. Taff said. When the weather is cold, insects are slow to emerge, leaving many birds with less food to bring back to the nest. “If it hits right at that really vulnerable stage, they don’t do very well,” Dr. Taff said.

The effect of heat waves was less pronounced, with 11 of the 24 species seeing a reduction in successful fledglings. With temperatures warming globally, many birds are nesting earlier in the spring when temperatures can fluctuate more wildly from warm to cold.

Future research could tie in data from eBird to more directly measure fledgling success rates and compare them with the size of local bird populations. “You can potentially match that up with whether there was a cold snap or heat wave during the breeding season and whether that’s affecting kind of the population level abundance,” Dr. Taff said.

The paper also shows that there is much to learn about how the changing climate will affect birds. It’s not even necessarily the extreme events like hurricanes or heat waves; more modest temperature shifts could also be deadly. “They’re obviously not good if they happen at a time that the birds are vulnerable,” Dr. Taff said.

Two European starlings hunt for snacks on a sidewalk just beneath some steps where people are sitting.
European starlings hunted for snacks at Columbus Circle in Manhattan. Even novice bird-watchers can attest that urban bird life includes far more than pigeons.Credit...Karsten Moran for The New York Times

I should probably begin with a confession: I am not a birder. There were even times when I found myself thinking that birds could be a little, er, boring. For years, I chalked my disinterest up to the fact that I lived in New York City, where the avian world seemed to begin and end with the pigeons I saw pecking at the street trash in my neighborhood.

Eventually I came to realize that the birds were not lacking; I was. My indifference was a failure of observation and imagination; even a novice bird-watcher could have told me that urban bird life includes far more than pigeons.

Of course, pigeons are remarkable in their own right. They have top-notch navigation skills, and their willingness to gobble down nearly any food item they encounter may be what secures their future in our ever-urbanizing world. Indeed, in a new study published in Nature Communications, researchers found that cities tend to favor bird species with broad diets.

“They can take advantage of resources as they become available,” said Frank La Sorte, a senior research associate at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, who was one of the authors of the study.

That is just one of the findings of the new paper, which explores the functional traits of urban animal communities around the globe. A large international team of researchers analyzed data not only on birds but also on bats, bees, beetles, reptiles and amphibians in 379 cities in 48 countries.

Image

Don’t discount the city pigeon — they have top-notch navigation skills and are remarkable for their willingness to gobble down nearly any food they can find.Credit...Yuvraj Khanna for The New York Times

The bird data, which encompassed 4,167 species in 177 cities, was derived from Cornell’s eBird database, which collects observations from bird-watchers around the world, including those participating in the Times summer birding project. The researchers tallied the species present in locations with different levels of urbanization and cataloged traits associated with each species, including its typical diet, body size and clutch size, or number of eggs a female bird typically lays at once.

The most highly urbanized sites were home to bird communities with smaller body sizes and clutch sizes, less mobility and more omnivorous diets than bird communities had in less urbanized areas, the researchers found. “These are species that do not require a tremendous amount of resources,” Dr. La Sorte said. “They can effectively use small patches of habitat they would find in parks or green spaces. They don’t have large home ranges. And they can effectively find enough food for their young.”

But the same patterns did not hold across all groups of animals. Urbanization tended to favor larger-bodied bats, for instance, perhaps because they are stronger fliers. And bees with narrow diets seemed to do relatively well in cities, which may offer a broader array of flowering plants than less urban areas.

Cities can make more species feel at home by providing a wider range of different habitat types, Dr. La Sorte said. For instance, many species rely on the dead and decaying wood that is plentiful in mature forests but hard to find in cities, where trees are usually carefully managed and manicured. “Including a patch of mature forest in a park is relatively easy to do,” he said. “Just don’t manage it anymore. Next thing you know, you’re introducing a whole host of new species.”

And citizen-scientists can help scientists learn more about what different species need in order to thrive. The study would not have been feasible without the contributions of “thousands and thousands” of volunteer bird watchers around the world, Dr. La Sorte said. “We want to show folks that this data is actually being used to advance different aspects of our understanding of bird ecology, in this case within urban settings.”

We asked readers what hurdles you have encountered while birding. Whether you are experienced or new to the activity, have you had any stumbling blocks that made you think twice about continuing? Respond in the comments.

We live in southeastern Arizona where summer temperatures make birding more challenging, especially this year when it’s been over 100 degrees Fahrenheit for the past month. The heat is tough on both birders and the birds they love. Getting an early start to arrive at a favorite spot before 5 a.m. is the best fix. We’re also making sure that the birds in our yard have plenty of water for drinking and cooling off.

—Diane Drobka Pima, Ariz.

“Do you know how much trouble I would be in if I’d hit you?” raged the golfer. And right he was to be incensed — I’d endangered us both. Without sufficiently surveying the scene, including the tee box about 25 yards away, I’d rushed over to the edge of the fairway. Why? To get a better look at the white pelicans blissfully floating on the pond, enjoying the balmy winter weather in Palm Springs, Calif.

—Gayle Smith Padgett, Saint-Remy-de-Provence, France

While sliding down the vertical swamp in Kaua’i’s Alaka’i Wilderness Preserve in search of the island’s six endemic bird species, I encountered a man in camouflage carrying a rifle and accompanied by two Rottweilers. We exchanged a tense greeting; he asked what I was doing there, laughed when I said “birding” and advised me to leave and not return. On my way out I saw his well-tended cannabis crop.

—Eliot Brenowitz, Seattle

Initially, whenever someone more experienced pointed out an overhead bird, I was lucky if I just saw a black speck. With time I trained my eyes to track the bird in flight and focus on spotting characteristics like color, head and chest markings, tail length. Unfortunately, about four months ago I was discovered to have a torn retina; for a while the floaters zoomed in my field of vision like fleeing birds.

—Christopher Sullivan, Akron, Ohio

I read an article on the topic of slow birding, where you spend more time observing closely and worry less about the count. This has improved my enjoyment of birding immensely. I still go birding with groups, but I also go alone, and often stay standing in the same spot for many minutes to let myself appreciate bird behaviors. It’s my meditation.

—Kathy Carson, Fremont, N.H.

The first barrier is safety, which wasn’t really a barrier because I didn’t let it stop me. Some of the best birding is in areas that may be remote or on little-used, uneven trails. As an older person, I worried that I might fall and break an ankle or hit my head and knock myself out (I did fall and severely twist my ankle, but I just wrapped it up and kept birding). Lucky for me, an acquaintance of mine took up birding and is as fanatical about it as I am. She will go anywhere at any time, and we get along marvelously, so now we are each other’s safety.

—Margaret Poethig, Arlington, Va.

Several bird enthusiasts, some wearing knapsacks or holding binoculars, gaze upward during a bird-watching outing in a forested area.
A birding walk in Singapore, one of three coordinated bird walks organized by BirdLife International along one in Manhattan another in Nairobi. The author recently joined an outing in the Bay Area organized by the Golden Gate Audubon Society.Credit...Scarlett Chan

Even with field guides and online encyclopedias, even with an app that can instantly identify birds from a few chirps, bird-watching can be hard.

Roughly half of the 30,000 Times readers who signed up to join the NYT birding project indicated that they were new to birding. Count me among them. I’ve honed the reflex to whip out the Merlin app to identify bird calls when I’m between work calls or on daily dog walks — yet I still struggle to actually remember what bird it was when I hear the melody again. Never mind the dots that fleet overhead, which experienced birders manage to name in seconds. Maybe, I thought, it was time to learn from people who have been doing it a while.

Recently we urged birding-project participants to join a local group outing. BirdLife International coordinated several walks in support of the Times project — one in Manhattan, one in Singapore and another in Nairobi, Kenya (more on those below). Where I live, in the San Francisco Bay Area, the Golden Gate Audubon Society organized outings, too; I joined two of them.

One started in the parking lot of a protected wildlife area called the Dotson Family Marsh, in Richmond, Calif. The group leader, David Mostardi, had barely introduced himself when he pointed a scope at an American kestrel that had perched on a nearby pylon. Two ospreys appeared overhead, and soon after we saw egrets flying close to the shore. All the while, Mr. Mostardi apologized for the lack of bird species compared to winter.

On the walk, we spotted a lone long-billed curlew by the water, about a dozen killdeer scurrying between shrubs and dozens of Canada geese, among other species. Fumbling with my binoculars, I struggled to see the various birds that people were calling out, until someone advised me to first look closely with “bare eyes.” It worked.

The second outing was in Blake Garden, a public garden in Kensington, Calif., that boasts more than 80 documented bird species. The group leader, Sonja Raub, urged silence as we listened to what she said were California towhees, then lesser goldfinches, then spotted towhees. Next she directed our attention, and our binoculars, to the redwood tree in front of us. “If you see the tree bark moving, it’s probably a brown creeper,” Ms. Raub said. But we were distracted by a Nuttall’s woodpecker that was hard to miss.

A nearby acacia tree offered more towhees, woodpeckers and — I’m pretty sure — a Pacific-slope flycatcher. Another tree supposedly housed a nest of Cooper’s hawks, but none were seen. Ms. Raub noted that raptors don’t usually emerge until the day warms up, and sometime after 9 a.m. we saw a red-tailed hawk sparring with a turkey vulture high above; a few minutes later, a red-shouldered hawk flew over.

I cast my binoculars between distant branches and then noted aloud, with some pride, that I could see a song sparrow sunning itself in a patch on the ground below. My fellow birders asked me how to find it, and for the first time in my birding career, I didn’t feel clueless.

To find a bird outing in your area, try the Audubon Near You tool.

Female and male red-winged blackbirds interact atop of feeders
Credit...Bing Guan for The New York Times

This week, we invite participants to try birding by ear. Practice identifying five species common to your area by their vocalizations. The Sound ID feature of the free Merlin Bird ID app can offer suggestions for which species are calling or singing around you. (People who are deaf or hard-of-hearing may find Merlin’s spectrograms helpful as visual representations of the sounds.)

Tell us: If you’re an experienced birder, share tips for identifying birds from their sounds. And if you’re trying this for the first time, let us know how it goes.

Michael Hurben, 56, first got into birding in his 20s. He also got interested in Claire Strohmeyer, who happened to be a more experienced birder. On their third date, when she mentioned that she was going on a walk with the Audubon Society, Mr. Hurben knew he had met the woman for him.

“I just lost it, because she had been doing this her whole life,” he said. “That was our instant bond. I wasn’t going to let her go after that.” They were married in 1993, and birding became the activity they did together, eventually taking them to 45 countries to see new species.

But just as Mr. Hurben’s interest in birding, and in Ms. Strohmeyer, was blossoming, his vision began to deteriorate. “It was nasty timing,” he said. “It used to really bother me to not see birds. I had to come to grips with that eventually.”

Although Mr. Hurben can no longer see at night and has no peripheral vision, he found a love of birding by ear. With a powerful microphone, he could identify and capture recordings of many birds without having to see them: “I said, ‘If I hear this and I get a recording of it, even if I don’t see it, I’m going to be happy with that.’

Mr. Hurben has now observed nearly half of all bird species in the world and recorded the vocalizations of nearly 1,000. His auditory birding skills are very finely tuned. “Eventually, they start becoming like human voices,” he said.

Many birders rely heavily on their ears to make identifications. “​​It is a living-in-the-moment experience,” Jocelyne, a summer birding project participant in Quebec, wrote. “I am totally concentrated on sounds, especially in summer when the foliage is often too thick to observe birds visually.”

Another participant, Barbara, who lives in California, writes: “I’m a singer, so the idea and process of training my ear to identify birds came naturally. I use Merlin to identify birds I haven’t heard before and to verify my guesses.”

Mr. Hurben noted that the Merlin Bird ID app can listen for bird calls and identify the likely source. But the time-tested method of birding alongside an experienced auditory birder was still golden, he said.

However you do it, birding by ear can be rewarding. “I’ve really had no choice,” Mr. Hurben said. “You don’t need to have a visual impairment to listen harder. You just have to make the effort.”

A crow’s nest incorporating strips of anti-bird spikes. Unlike the magpies, the crows have arranged the strips with the spikes pointing inward.
A crow’s nest collected from Rotterdam in 2021. Unlike the magpies, the crows arranged the strips with the spikes pointing inward.Credit...Kees Moeliker

Auke-Florian Hiemstra, a biologist who studies how wild animals repurpose human materials, thought he had seen everything. In his research on the common coot, a water bird often found in Dutch canals, he had discovered nests containing windshield wipers, sunglasses, plastic carnations, condoms and envelopes used to package cocaine.

“So my definition of what is nesting material was already quite a broad one,” said Mr. Hiemstra, a doctoral student at the Naturalis Biodiversity Center in the Netherlands. “Almost anything can become part of a bird nest.”

Still, he was not prepared for what he found when he went to investigate a strange nest that had been spotted outside a hospital in Antwerp, Belgium, in July 2021. Nestled near the top of a sugar maple tree was a Eurasian magpie nest that resembled a cyberpunk porcupine, with thin metal rods sticking out in every direction.

“I couldn’t believe my eyes,” he recalled. “These are birds making a nest with anti-bird spikes.”

A close-up photograph of a hand holding a pen, which draws a bird’s head in black ink.
“There’s a real, deep, personal satisfaction and reward for taking the time to really watch a bird and study it and figure out how to draw it,” David Sibley, the famed artist and birder, said. Credit...Spencer Weiner/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

This week, for the New York Times summer birding project, we invite birders to try their hand at drawing a bird. You can do this from life or from a photograph. Try to produce at least one sketch in the upcoming week. Share it with us by emailing birds@nytimes.com.

You don’t need to spend hours honing your illustration (unless you want to). As the master illustrator David Sibley, of the widely popular Sibley field guides, describes in the interview below, the most important aspect of drawing a bird may just be that it changes how you see.

This interview has been edited for clarity and length.

Do you have any formal training in illustration?

No, I am self-taught.

I should say that I don’t consider myself really an artist as much as a scientific illustrator. I am trying to convey information, and it’s all about the details of the bird: the shape, the posture, the colors, the patterns. The outline is the most important part; if that’s right, everything else sort of falls into place, and it’s just like a coloring book.

How often, and where, do you go birding?

I’m lucky now to live in a place where I can just step outside and walk into the woods or around some fields and go birding right here. But I am always aware of birds. I am listening and watching through a window or along the road — wherever I am, I am always birding.

Do you think technology will ever replace illustration in the birding world?

I’ve wondered about that. I don’t think so. An illustration provides so much more than a photograph. In an illustration, I can create a typical bird, an average bird of a species in the exact pose that I want, and create an image of a similar species in exactly the same pose so that all the differences are apparent. And I control the lighting and the color. You just can’t get that with photographs; photographs are always a record of one individual bird at one instant in time.

One of my concerns is that the craft of illustration might disappear, that the motivation for someone to put in the time to learn a subject like this, to be able to produce the illustrations — there might not be the same kind of incentive to do that. There’s a real, deep, personal satisfaction and reward for taking the time to really watch a bird and study it and figure out how to draw it.

How has spending so much time illustrating birds and ruminating on them shaped your understanding of the natural world and of birds?

It has really shaped the way I think about everything. Drawing is a way of slowing down to take the time to look at something, and drawing also gives you a record of what you thought you saw. It’s not like a photograph; it’s your interpretation of what you saw.

Getting better at drawing is partly about developing technical skill, but it’s more about getting to know the subject. Your drawing becomes a record of your understanding of that bird in that moment. Drawing in that way encourages you to be a more thoughtful observer.

How to Draw a Bird the David Sibley Way

Camille Baker
Camille BakerSketching in New York City

For The Times’s summer birding project, I spoke to the field guide illustrator about how to sketch a bird. Here’s how he draws a black-capped chickadee →

David Sibley

A barred owl sits in a tree.
Credit...Dave Sanders for The New York Times

This week, for The New York Times’s summer birding project, we invite beginners to try birding at two different times of day for at least five minutes each. Note what you observe and compare. Are certain species more abundant or vocal at particular hours? How does the behavior of various species differ?

Report back with your observations in the comments section.

You might think of a birder as the type to rise at 5 a.m., slip on a bulky pair of rain boots and plod off into a muddy marsh to spot a rare sparrow just as the sun begins to peek over the horizon — and to do it all in time to be home for breakfast.

But the truth is, “any time is a good time to go birding,” said Kevin McGowan, an instructor at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology.

Early birders have the best chance of catching a lot of activity, as many species begin to vocalize and feed to greet the day. During the early morning, “people can hear things like thrushes singing that are much less frequent later, ” Dr. McGowan said.

Even the early afternoon, the hottest part of the day and often considered the most challenging time to bird, can be a great time to spot certain species, Dr. McGowan said. Many birds rest when the sun is high, but raptors such as eagles and hawks soar on updrafts that form when sunlight warms the ground. Vultures, another raptor, are easy to spot in the early afternoon because they “get up on the thermals and fly miles and miles and miles” looking for food, he said.

Around dusk, many species become more active again, making it another popular time for birding. This may be partly territorial, Dr. McGowan said. He said that birds are letting others know, “Hey, I made it through the day. Don’t bother coming over here and trying to steal my wife.”

But good birding doesn’t stop after sundown. Whip-poor-wills and nighthawks, for example, feed on moths and other flying insects at night, foraging when there is less competition with other species. And owls, whose finely adapted hearing makes them fierce predators, “rule the night,” Dr. McGowan said.

Nighttime birders should keep three things in mind to maximize their sightings, he said. First, consider the habitat where you’re observing: Birds may be more active near bodies of water at night, whereas forests tend to be pretty quiet. Second, move quietly: Stick to established trails or roads to avoid making noise and scaring away wildlife. And third, be prepared to identify birds by their vocalizations. Future prompts will explore auditory identification in greater depth, but for now the Merlin Bird ID app can help.

“Birding at night is not about what you see, but about what you hear,” Margaret Poethig, one participant in the New York Times birding project, wrote in to say. Ms. Poethig was lucky enough to hear barred owls exchange calls during a nighttime survey of breeding birds in the Maryland/D.C. area. “I feel like my heart stops in moments like these when I’m birding,” she wrote.

Several bird-watchers stand in a group looking up at the trees. Some are using binoculars.
The birding app from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology filters observations from volunteers and tracks new behaviors in birds.Credit...Melissa Golden for The New York Times

You’ve decided to take up birding. You’ve even decided to use eBird, an app from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology that collects sightings by birders around the world.

After going out and looking for birds, making a list of what you’ve seen and checking it twice, you submit it to Cornell …

And then what? What does Cornell do with your checklist?

“It doesn’t go to a black hole,” said Jenna Curtis, one of the leaders of the eBird project. “A lot of things happen all at once when an observation gets submitted.”

Birders sometimes make mistakes, but Dr. Curtis hopes that people using apps like eBird, especially beginners, aren’t deterred by the fear that they are wrong. Sometimes what seemed to be a mistake turns out to be a new discovery.

First, your observations are checked for obvious errors — no penguins in Oregon or Australian kookaburras in Poughkeepsie, for example.

“Every eBird observation is run through an automatic filter,” Dr. Curtis said. “It’s a computer-based filter that checks what you’re reporting against what’s expected.”

The filters are set by local volunteer experts who are familiar with the distribution and timing of birds in the area, Dr. Curtis said, and there’s a filter for every location in the world, including the middle of the ocean.

The filters also take into account the time of year. For instance, a sighting of a Baltimore oriole in Baltimore right now makes sense. Maryland falls within the orioles’ breeding ground, which stretches across eastern and central North America. But a sighting in December, when Baltimore orioles are wintering in Florida, the Caribbean, Central America and the northern tip of South America, would not fit.

Image

A Brooklynite using eBird, an app from the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, that collects sightings by birders around the world.Credit...Caroline Tompkins for The New York Times

If the observations match what is expected, they are immediately added to the eBird database for use by scientists and other birders.

If the computer filter spots something that does not seem quite right, it flags the checklist for review by one of more than 2,000 volunteers. “A red flag appears next to those observations before you even submit the data,” Dr. Curtis said.

The app will ask for a detailed description of the bird and “as much information as possible to help another human being understand and appreciate the experience that you’re having,” Dr. Curtis said. “It’s not something to question people or say, you know, we don’t believe you. It’s an opportunity to share the unusual thing that you’re reporting with other people.”

Sometimes it’s an innocent mistake of misidentification. A report of a blue jay in Oregon, where Dr. Curtis lives, would be questioned, because blue jays generally do not fly that far west. “We have a different species of jay called scrub jay,” Dr. Curtis said. “And that’s a good opportunity to say, ‘Hmm, maybe I should double-check the range of blue jays.’”

And sometimes that flagged observation could reflect something new and different in the behavior of that bird. “Whenever those things appear,” Dr. Curtis said, “I’m like, ‘Oh, this is an exciting moment. This is potentially something unusual and noteworthy.’”

That included an eagle that turned up thousands of miles from where it should have been a couple of years ago. Steller’s sea eagles are rare Arctic birds with bright orange beaks, and their native range is typically China, Japan, Korea and the east coast of Russia.

Some have flown into Alaska, but in 2021 one of the birds, nicknamed Stella, made it all the way across North America to Nova Scotia, a behavior that scientists describe as avian vagrancy. This, Dr. Curtis said, was “a great example of how the geographic coverage of eBirders helps to find and follow individual birds that might otherwise slip through the cracks.”

Christian Cooper and Amy Tan came to birding from very different paths. Cooper had found refuge in birding as a child, long before the Central Park incident that brought him to national attention. For Tan, birding was a more recent discovery, prompted by a need for an outlet away from political events.

For both, birding has been a powerful source of solace and community. In a free, live discussion on Thursday, June 22, Cooper, the author of the new book “Better Living Through Birding,” and Tan, author of the forthcoming book “The Backyard Bird Chronicles,” spoke about the transcendent power of birding and the challenges and the rewards of navigating a predominantly white pastime as people of color. The conversation was hosted by Dodai Stewart, a birding enthusiast and a Metro writer for The New York Times.

We also discussed how you can start birding as part of the New York Times summer birding project. Thousands of people have already signed up to learn more about birds and to help scientists collect birding data during the summer season, when fewer observations are typically submitted. Alan Burdick, an editor on the science desk at The Times, spoke with Jenna Curtis of the Cornell Lab of Ornithology about the importance of gathering this data. Plus, we heard tips from other birders.

Credit...Wesley Allsbrook

Below is an excerpt from Christian Cooper’s essay in the Times Opinion section.

Early in the morning of May 25, 2020, I biked from my apartment on Manhattan’s Lower East Side to Central Park to go birding in the Ramble. Despite the uncertainties of the time — New Yorkers were living in a hot spot of the raging Covid pandemic, with no vaccine in sight — I strove to start this warm, sunlit Memorial Day on a happy note by wandering my favorite urban woodlands in search of migrating songbirds.

I was focused on the end-of-season hunt for a mourning warbler, a small yellow and gray skulking bird that’s difficult to spot and relatively rare. I hadn’t yet seen one that year.

Visiting the park in the morning to look for birds has long been a springtime routine for me. I wake before sunrise and grab my Swarovski binoculars — a 50th-birthday present from my father — and head out the door.

On that particular day, just as I approached some ideal mourning warbler habitat, a noise shattered the tranquillity, making me wince. The sound was loud, strident and unmistakable: a person calling after a dog.

Credit...Dave Sanders for The New York Times

Our colleague at Wirecutter, Dan Koeppel, offered this step-by-step guide to birding from inside your home.

There are lots of things to look at from the window of my third-floor apartment in Portland, Maine. There’s a nice view of 19th-century rowhouses and brick sidewalks. There’s Casco Bay, in the distance, with a string of rocky islands and the ferries shuttling between them. There are the idled container ships at the port’s terminals, waiting for commerce to begin again. And there are three different kinds of gulls.

The most common gull — the one you’ll recognize — is the gray-and-white herring gull. But there are two others as well, and using an electronic bird identification guide, it’s pretty easy to figure out what species they are. Their names give them away: the great black-backed gull is large and dark; the ring-billed gull’s beak is encircled by a telltale hoop.

The gulls were the first birds I added to my window list when quarantine began in March 2020. In my first two months birding, I counted another 10 distinct species.

You might be able to see even more, all without leaving the comfort of your home. Depending on your location, your window or yard list could reach 200 or more individual bird species. We’ll go into more details below, but the best place to start is by assembling birding basics.

A person in a pink shirt decorated with a long-billed bird looks upward through binoculars.
A birding enthusiast in Brooklyn with binoculars, which are helpful for finding more birds but not a necessity.Credit...Kirsten Luce for The New York Times

As part of the New York Times birding project, The Times has a series of prompts to help readers learn how to get started birding. Begin with something foundational: Learn to identify a few of the birds most commonly seen near where you live.

For beginner tips, The Times spoke with Alli Smith, the project coordinator for Merlin — a bird-identification app created by the Cornell Lab of Ornithology — about learning to bird, and the joy of it.

How do I learn to identify birds?

We’re obviously a little bit biased here, so I’m going to recommend the Merlin Bird ID app. It walks you through a series of five questions that you should be asking yourself when you’re looking at a bird.

Merlin will ask you where you saw the bird specifically and the time of year. A lot of places see different birds depending on the season.

Then, observing the bird for a while can really help. Is it tiny, like a house sparrow? Is it really big, like a goose? And the colors of the bird can help as well. Is it bright and yellow and colorful? Is it solid black?

And then the behavior: What is it doing? Is it visiting a bird feeder? There’s a very small list, relatively, of birds that are likely to visit a bird feeder compared with birds that are elsewhere in the environment. Is it spending a lot of time perched in a tree? Is it walking around on the ground? Is it in the water swimming?

With all of these things put together, Merlin can give you a list of likely birds. But even if you’re not using Merlin, those are the types of things that you should be looking for: the size, color, behavior, location and date.

What equipment do I need to start birding?

Binoculars, field guides or cameras — or travel — might help you find more birds or get closer looks at them. But you definitely don’t need any of those.

What should I keep in mind while birding in the summer?

Birds are generally quietest during the hottest part of the day, so you’ll probably see a lot more if you’re going birding from sunrise, like 6 a.m. until 10 a.m. or so. Once it starts to get hot, birds really start to quiet down. They hide more in the shade. But if you can only get out during the middle of the day, try places that tend to attract birds, like near water. And then evenings can be really nice, too. Two or three hours before sunset, birds start to get more active.

What do you enjoy about birding?

I am just so deeply delighted that I get to share my neighborhood, my world, with these tiny, feathered balls of energy that are bouncing around and singing beautiful songs and doing all these really wacky and wonderful behaviors, like weaving nests out of grass and showing off their shiny feathers. Each bird is its own little treasure. Even the common birds around here, like the grackles and house sparrows — they’re so fun to watch. They’re really goofy.

It’s also special when you get to see a more rare bird. I think they’re so inspiring, these tiny birds that are able to fly from the southern tip of South America all the way up to Canada, Alaska, the Arctic to breed. And they do that twice a year. That’s absolutely incredible. They’re tiny and yet so determined and powerful.

This interview has been edited for clarity and length.

An illustration of a graph transforming into music notes coming out of a bird’s mouth on the left and going toward a human’s ear on the right.
Credit...Fiona Carswell

When a bird sings, you may think you’re hearing music. But are the melodies it’s making really music? Or is what we’re hearing merely a string of lilting calls that appeals to the human ear?

Birdsong has inspired musicians from Bob Marley to Mozart and perhaps as far back as the first hunter-gatherers who banged out a beat. And a growing body of research is showing that the affinity human musicians feel toward birdsong has a strong scientific basis. Scientists are understanding more about avian species’ ability to learn, interpret and produce songs much like our own.

Just like humans, birds learn songs from each other and practice to perfect them. And just as human speech is distinct from human music, bird calls, which serve as warnings and other forms of direct communication, differ from birdsong.

While researchers are still debating the functions of birdsong, studies show that it is structurally similar to our own tunes. So, are birds making music? That depends on what you mean.

An illustrated view on a white background of Caihong juji, which has vibrant blue, green, yellow and reddish plumage around its head, neck and shoulders, and the rest of its feathering colored black.
Caihong juji, a 160 million-year-old bird-like dinosaur found in Hebei Province in China, which had an iridescent, rainbow crest.Credit...Velizar Simeonovski/University of Texas, Austin

In 1993, “Jurassic Park” helped inspire 9-year-old Stephen Brusatte to become a paleontologist. So Dr. Brusatte was thrilled to advise the producers of last year’s “Jurassic World: Dominion” on what scientists had learned about dinosaurs since he was a child.

He was especially happy to see one of the most important discoveries make it to the screen: dinosaurs that sported feathers. But judging from the emails he has been receiving, some moviegoers did not share his excitement.

“A lot of people thought it was made up,” said Dr. Brusatte, a professor at the University of Edinburgh. “They thought it was filmmakers trying to do something crazy.”

Far from crazy, feathered dinosaurs have become a well-established fact, thanks largely to a trove of remarkable fossils that have been unearthed in northeast China since the mid-1990s. Now Dr. Brusatte and other paleontologists are trying to determine exactly how feathered dinosaurs achieved powered flight and became the birds that fly overhead today — an evolutionary mystery that stretches more than 150 million years.

An illustration shows a dark brown nest holding two eggs that have been cracked open. The eggs are off-white with reddish-brown spots. Gray feathers lie in the nest, which sits on a gray rock. The rock is strewed with egg shell fragments and another gray feather. The background consists of green grass, trees and other plants and a white picket fence.
Credit...Michelle Mildenberg

Daryln Brewer Hoffstot, a freelance writer in Pennsylvania, is worried about the eastern phoebes around her home.

She thought at first that a nesting female living by her back door could be an eastern wood-pewee, another grayish-white flycatcher with a short bill, but the giveaway was the way the eastern phoebe wagged her tail when she flew off the nest.

Eastern phoebes are in the flycatcher family and consume not just flies but also wasps, grasshoppers and even ticks — great news to those of us who can’t walk in the woods without getting bitten. Native to North America, they also eat small berries from plants such as Virginia creeper. The bird’s call is like its name: an onomatopoeic “fee bee.”

One day last spring when Hoffstot went to check on the mother bird, she found three raw and naked eastern phoebe nestlings tossed onto the porch floor. At first, she suspected brown-headed cowbirds, famous for raiding nests. But she had observed house sparrows divebombing the back door, which she had never seen before, and then she learned that while brown-headed cowbirds often remove eggs to make room for their own, they don’t dump out nestlings.

A close-up view of a bird's nest resting on a branch in a tree with a blurry background.
Credit...Andrew Spear for The New York Times

If a bird is not in a forest and there is no one to see that it is not there, is it really not there?

That, in essence, is the conundrum that the Cornell Lab of Ornithology is confronting. For more than two decades, the lab has run eBird, a project that collects observations from amateur bird watchers. It is a successful project: Nearly 900,000 participants around the world have submitted some 18 million lists a year of what they have spotted during their bird-watching sessions. And the number of lists has been growing at a pace of some 20 percent a year.

That has proved to be a trove for scientists to study changes in populations and behavior of birds, revealing “complex relationships between people and birds in ways that we couldn’t have before,” said Tom Auer, who leads the geospatial data science team at the Cornell lab.

For example, the voluminous eBird data has established how the bright lights of big cities draw in migratory birds, especially young ones. And cities, with their canyons of concrete and asphalt, are generally poor habitats for birds. Cornell scientists are now studying whether the diversion leads to exhaustion and starvation, and whether fewer birds survive the migratory journey.

But, as the project relies on the efforts of volunteers, the data does not cover all places equally. “You can imagine obvious places where there aren’t data,” Mr. Auer said. “Mostly because people are drawn to places where they can see the most birds.”

Neglected areas include farmland and industrial tracts. The sparsity of data affects the ability to answer questions like whether a change in farming practices helps or hurts birds. “It helps if people can spread out and can cover wider habitats,” Mr. Auer said.

For scientists, knowing where birds are not is as important as knowing where they are. That can reveal declining populations, shifting habitats or changes in migration.

That is a tall ask, though — a social experiment in asking people to go out of the way to places where there are probably fewer birds to spot.

Mr. Auer also said that the lab would like to recruit not just experienced bird-watchers but also those who are just learning to identify various species. “Having that variety of skill levels actually improves the quality of research we do,” he said.

The newcomers will generally be less observant and make more mistakes, but a lot of errors are caught when Cornell reviews the data, and new watchers can provide a useful comparison to the more experienced observers.

“If we didn’t have beginning birders to compare to expert birders, we wouldn’t really know how good the expert birders were at detecting birds,” Mr. Auer said. “We’ve done tests with our models, where we remove beginning birders, and when we do that, the models perform more poorly than if we included the beginners.”

A black-and-white photo of a woodpecker perched on the extended arm of a person.
An ivory-billed woodpecker in the Singer Tract, Louisiana, in 1938. The last widely accepted sighting was in 1944. Credit...James T. Tanner/Science Source

If there’s new hope, it’s blurry. What’s certain: The roller coaster tale of the ivory-billed woodpecker, a majestic bird whose presumed extinction has been punctuated by a series of contested rediscoveries, is going strong.

The latest twist is a peer-reviewed study Thursday in the journal Ecology and Evolution presenting sighting reports, audio recordings, trail camera images and drone video. Collected over the last decade in a Louisiana swamp forest, the precise location omitted for the birds’ protection, the authors write that the evidence suggests the “intermittent but repeated presence” of birds that look and behave like ivory-billed woodpeckers.

But are they?

“It’s this cumulative evidence from our multiyear search that leaves us very confident that this iconic species exists, and it persists in Louisiana and probably other places as well,” said Steven C. Latta, one of the study’s authors and director of conservation and field research at the National Aviary, a nonprofit bird zoo in Pittsburgh that helps lead a program that searches for the species.

But Dr. Latta acknowledges that no single piece of evidence is definitive, and the study is carefully tempered with words like “putative” and “possible.”

Therein lies the problem. As one expert wrote during a previous ivory bill go-round: “The body of evidence is only as strong as the single strongest piece — ten cups of weak coffee do not make a pot of strong coffee.”

This time, two experts who have been skeptical of previous sightings said they remained unconvinced.

“The trouble is, it’s all very poor video,” said Chris Elphick, a professor of conservation biology at the University of Connecticut who studies birds. Pileated and red-headed woodpeckers, among other species, can look a lot like ivory bills from a distance or from certain angles. Light can play games with the eye. Audio is easy to misconstrue.

“I don’t think this changes very much, frankly,” he said. “I would love to be wrong.”

Video

Video from October 2022. Two birds, possibly ivory-billed woodpeckers, enter the frame from the mid-right margin.CreditCredit...Latta, Michaels, et al., Ecology and Evolution 2023

The stakes of the recent findings are heightened because federal wildlife officials have proposed that ivory-billed woodpeckers be declared extinct, which would end legal protection. Last year, citing “substantial disagreement among experts regarding the status of the species,” the United States Fish and Wildlife Service extended its deadline to make a final ruling.

A spokeswoman, Christine Schuldheisz, said the agency did not comment on outside studies but was working toward a final decision, which is expected later this year.

According to the authors of the new study, removing federal protection would be bad for any remaining ivory bills. But other scientists say there’s a steep price to keeping them on the endangered species list.

“Whether or not limited federal conservation funds should be spent on chasing this ghost, instead of saving other genuinely endangered species and habitats, is a vital issue,” said Richard O. Prum, a professor of ornithology at Yale.

Ivory bills fell into steep decline as Americans logged their habitat, old-growth swampy forests of the Southeast. Few remained by the 1930s, but a scientific expedition discovered a nest in Louisiana, in one of the largest remaining swaths of habitat. The land, called the Singer Tract, was leased for logging. Conservation groups tried to purchase the rights, but the company refused to sell. The last widely accepted ivory bill sighting in the United States was in 1944, a lone female, seen in her roost with the forest cleared around her.

Since then, purported sightings have sparked joy and backlash. One, in 1967, was heralded on the front page of The New York Times. Twenty years later, another one, in Cuba, where a subspecies or similar species may or may not hang on, was also reported on Page One. In 2002, searchers in Louisiana thought they’d captured audio of the ivory bill’s distinctive double rap, but a computer analysis determined the sound to be distant gunshots. A reported sighting in Arkansas in 2004 led to a paper in Science and flurry of bird tourism, but that evidence was heavily criticized.

Image

Mark A. Michaels, left, and Steven C. Latta, two of the study’s authors.Credit...Project Principalis

To Dr. Elphick, a birder as well as a scientist, one of the most telling results is what so much effort has not yielded: a single clear photograph.

“There are these incredibly rare birds that live in the middle of the Amazon that people can get good, identifiable photographs of,” Dr. Elphick said. “And yet people have spent hundreds of thousands of hours trying to find and photograph ivory-billed woodpeckers in the United States. If there’s really a population out there, it’s inconceivable to me that no one could get a good picture.”

But Dr. Latta, the study co-author, insisted that he had seen one clearly with his own eyes. He was in the field in 2019 to set up recording units, and he figures he spooked the bird. As it flew up and away, he got a close, unimpeded view of its signature markings.

“I couldn’t sleep for, like, three days,” Dr. Latta said. “It was because I had this opportunity and I felt this responsibility to establish for the rest of the world, or at least the conservation world, that this bird actually does exist.”

An illustration of a bird in front of a yellow and orange map that appears to be torn. Near its beak, there are two black arrows and some text that reads “200 mile, depth of atmosphere.”
Credit...Mike McQuade

Our understanding of birds has been profoundly shaped by the work of everyday people. After all, anyone can step outside and pay attention to the untamed world swooping above.

We invited readers, both new and experienced birders, to participate in a science project we worked on with the Cornell Lab of Ornithology. We gathered observations about the birds around us, filling in data gaps and giving researchers a clearer picture of biodiversity.

It’s important work. Nearly half of all bird species worldwide are known or suspected to be in decline, and climate change could accelerate this trend.

For beginners, we provided a series of birding challenges to help put them on the path toward contributing scientific data. For experienced birders, we had a bit more to ask. Cornell’s scientific database typically receives fewer birding observations in the summer. So we asked readers to submit as often as possible, even if it was just to record the common birds in their areas.

The project brought together a global community of readers, scientists and researchers who engaged in online discussions and shared what they learned to help others. We also had a virtual event with Christian Cooper and Amy Tan on the joy of birding.

The citizen science project culminated in a showcase at a Times climate event, which included a video about the work, an exhibit and other features.

Though the Times project has wrapped up, birding is a yearlong activity. The Cornell Lab has a slate of citizen science efforts, along with its free apps, Merlin, a reference and identification tool, and eBird, which sends user observations to Cornell’s database, used by scientists around the world.

We’re so glad you’re taking part in our summer birding project! Tell us in the comments what got you interested in birding. And if you are just getting started, let us know what you could use help with. We may share your comment in New York Times newsletters and articles.