Give Your Worn-Out Bed New Life With Our Favorite Mattress Toppers

Our Top Picks

The Bear Pro Mattress Topper was our clear winner after several weeks of testing. This heavy-duty topper hit the mark on all fronts, and we loved its Goldilocks construction of plushness and support. We were so impressed by the topper's feel upon arrival that we laid it directly on the hardwood floor and found it surprisingly comfortable.

This topper isn't just our favorite pick overall; it's also the best foam mattress topper we've tested. That's because it offers body-cradling support without causing you to sink into the bed. Our new mom tester found the topper's pressure relief to be a dream after a long day of carrying a 20-pound baby. It also supported multiple sleeping positions and didn’t make any noise with tossing and turning.

At 3 inches thick, this topper is plenty hefty enough to transform the comfort level of overly-firm mattresses. Its weight also makes the topper stay in place well, and we didn’t experience any shifting or sliding throughout the testing period. That said, it’s quite bulky and a bit of a struggle to set up and place on the bed, so you may want to recruit some help. But once it’s on, we found the effort to be well worth it.

Throughout the testing period, we observed no signs of wear or changes in texture. It kept its shape nicely and never flattened, which is a good sign of its durability and resilience. While we haven’t needed to clean this topper yet, we appreciate that it comes with a machine-washable zip cover for easy care, like most of the options on this list. 

While we did notice a strong plastic-y odor out of the package, it has dissipated over the span of a few weeks.

_{Material: Memory foam | Thickness: 3 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: 30 nights | Warranty: 2-year limited}

The Threshold 2-in Cool Touch Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper offers a comparable feel to other premium mattress toppers on the market at a fraction of the cost. We added this topper to a 13-year-old pillow top mattress that was old but in decent condition, and we were surprised with how much plushness the 2-inch topper provided.

This option is definitely on the softer side, providing a sink-in feel we absolutely loved. We found the 2-inch size plenty plush considering the state of our mattress, but it also comes with a 3-inch version if you want a bit more cushioning. While we don’t think it’ll provide much additional support, it’s a great option if your main priority is adding comfort.

This topper wasn’t very firm, but we loved its pressure relief. Our tester, who historically felt soreness when side sleeping, never felt any pain or discomfort when using this mattress topper. We think this would be a great choice for most sleepers, as we found it enhanced the comfort of every sleeping position.

Although this is marketed as a cooling mattress topper, we didn’t think it delivered much on that front—but neither did most of the options we tested, especially with a fitted sheet on tip. While we like nearly everything about this topper, we recommend the GhostBed Cooling Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper if you’re looking for a slightly cooler option.

_{Material: Memory foam | Thickness: 2 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: 365 nights | Warranty: Not listed}

Latex can be a great option for those looking for a breathable, resilient, and supportive mattress topper—and we particularly love Saatva’s Natural Latex Mattress Topper. If you have a mattress that's too soft, a latex topper can provide the extra support you need. It’s on the thinner side at just about 1.5 inches thick, but we think its moderate density makes it very effective.

We’d describe this mattress topper as medium-firm, but not hard or uncomfortable. While it still conforms to sleepers’ bodies, we found the topper provides a more buoyant and resilient feel. We think it’s a great option if you prefer to sit comfortably at the surface of your mattress topper versus sinking in. 

We liked how supported we felt, especially in our lower back and hips. Throughout the testing period, we never woke up with any pain or discomfort. Our tester, who has sporadic neck stiffness, has yet to experience that with this topper. We also found this topper quite durable, with a buoyant, flattening-resistant construction.

One of our favorite aspects of this product is its built-in elastic straps, which secure the topper to the mattress. Shifting and sliding can be a common issue among mattress toppers, especially if it doesn’t fit perfectly. This thoughtful design detail prevents that completely, and the straps were generously sized to fit most mattresses.

We think it’s worth noting, though, that this mattress topper has a shorter warranty period compared to the other options on our list. It's not a dealbreaker, in our opinion, given the durability of latex, but it’s worth keeping in mind before purchasing.

_{Material: Latex | Thickness: 1.5 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, split king, California king | Trial Period: 180 nights | Warranty: 1-year limited}

Add an extra layer of luxurious and pillowy comfort with the Parachute Down Alternative Mattress Topper. This option doesn’t look like or feel like your average memory foam or latex option—rather, we think it resembles a fluffy comforter. This is a great pick for those looking to add a bit of softness to their mattresses, and it’s by far the plushest topper on this list.

It’s the perfect addition to too-firm mattresses that aren’t lacking in support. This 3-inch topper is filled with plush microfiber and features a baffle-box design to ensure even loft and comfort. The topper's hypoallergenic down-alternative filling is wrapped in a smooth, soft cotton sateen shell.

We’re obsessed with the cloud-like comfort this topper provides. We found it comfortable in every sleeping position, and it drastically improved the feel of our bed. It hasn’t flattened despite nightly use over the course of six months, which has seriously impressed us.

Unlike the other options on this list, the Parachute Down Alternative Mattress Topper is not machine washable, nor does it have a machine washable cover. Like many of the best comforters out there, this topper is dry-clean only. Additionally, you’ll want to make sure you fluff this mattress topper monthly to keep it fluffy. 

_{Material: Cotton, microfiber | Thickness: 3 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: 60 nights | Warranty: 3-year limited}

If you're struggling with aches and pains from a soft mattress, a topper like the Casper Comfy can remedy this. This topper offers a firmer feel, providing excellent support. This was very comfortable in every position, but we’d especially recommend it for side sleepers, who need a supportive surface to prevent the shoulders, hips, and spine from excessive sinking.

The topper's two-layer foam design provides a medium firmness, but in testing we found it leaned noticeably more supportive for our backs than plush and body-cradling. The material is incredibly resilient, always bouncing back to its original shape after use. And while the topper’s main draw is its ample support, we also found it to be cushiony and comfortable as well. It’s 3 inches thick, and we found that it made a noticeable difference on the bed.

This is also one of the most temperature-regulating options on this list, and we found that the bed tends to feel cooler for longer with the topper on. It also stays nicely in place, without any shifting or sliding. 

After six months of at-home testing, we’re really impressed with how well it has held up. Our tester, who previously experienced soreness and aches in the morning, reports significant relief since using this topper. While this topper isn’t super plush, we think it’s a great option for anyone looking to add more support to their existing mattress or just prefer a firmer sleep surface.

_{Material: Foam, memory foam | Thickness: 3 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: 30 nights | Warranty: 5-year limited}

I think comfortable and supportive mattress toppers are a worthy investment considering the impact they've had on my own sleep health. While the Tempur-Pedic Tempur Adapt+ Mattress Topper is on the pricey end of the spectrum, it made a world of difference when added to my 14-year-old run-down mattress. 

My previous mattress was lumpy and uncomfortable, but the addition of the topper really transformed its feel. I'm a restless sleeper, and after weeks of testing this topper I noticed significant improvement in my sleep quality. I love how well it conforms nicely to the body, providing pressure relief to the neck, shoulders, and back.

While this topper definitely leans on the plusher side, I didn’t find it lacking support. While it offers a soft, sinking feel, it maintains its shape and never flattens. It feels great in every position, and I think it’s especially comfortable for back sleepers.

After seven months, I'm still a huge fan of this mattress topper. The 3-inch-thick topper never flattened or deflated despite consistent use. I did notice slight shifting and sliding over time, but this was easily mitigated with a small adjustment.

_{Material: Memory foam | Thickness: 3 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: None | Warranty: 10-year limited}

Struggle with overheating at night? The Ghostbed Cooling Gel Memory Foam Mattress Topper is one of the only mattress toppers we’ve tried that delivers effective temperature regulation properties. This topper kept us cool and comfortable throughout the night, a rare find among the options we tested.

It’s also one of the most comfortable mattress toppers we’ve tried, as it molds to the body and provides a plush feel. Like a lot of our favorite options, this mattress topper is made from memory foam. It’s also infused with gel, which helps improve heat dispersion.

Its unique design sets it apart from the rest—this mattress topper offers zoned support for your head, shoulders, torso, legs, and feet. This is achieved through the topper’s contoured surface, which we suspect also encourages ample airflow.

We’ve tested this option in our homes for six months, and our hot sleeper tester is still a huge fan. In fact, we’ve found it helps reduce the amount of tossing and turning at night, and our sleep quality has improved while using it. Just note that this option has a strong scent upon arrival, which may require you to air it out for a bit before use.

_{Material: Gel memory foam | Thickness: 3 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: 101 nights | Warranty: 5-year limited}

The ViscoSoft Serene Hybrid Mattress Topper, in our opinion, combines the best of both memory foam and pillowtop mattress toppers, and it’ll completely transform your mattress. Its hybrid design is the thickest option on this list, too, at a whopping 4 inches thick.

The base is a gel-infused memory foam, and on top is a pillowtop filled with 380 GSM down-alternative filling. We tried this topper on a worn-down mattress and found that it helped reduce aches and pains from our previous mattress. The topper molded to our bodies, relieving pressure points and providing a comfortable sleep surface.

The pillowtop offers comfortable plushness, while the memory foam provides impressive support. It held up really well over the span of six months, and there have been no changes or signs of wear. Note that you will have to fluff the pillowtop every now and again, which is par for the course when it comes to toppers with down-alternative filling.

It’s always a good idea to check any mattress topper’s dimensions before buying, but we found it’s particularly important if you’re considering this one. We found the sizing a bit funky. This topper is slightly larger than our mattress at home, so it hung over the edge of the bed. Additionally, this topper may not be the best option if you’re looking for something particularly cooling, as the pillowtop can tend to retain heat a bit.

_{Material: Memory foam, down alternative | Thickness: 3, 4 inches | Available Sizes: Twin, twin XL, full, queen short, queen, king, California king | Trial Period: 90 days | Warranty: 5-year limited}

Final Verdict

Our overall best mattress topper is the Bear Pro Mattress Topper, which offers a plush and body-cradling feel that’s great for every sleep position. For something a bit firmer, we love the  Casper Comfy Mattress Topper. It offers ample support and also excels in temperature regulation.

Read Next

• The 8 Best Mattresses to Upgrade Your Sleep

• After Testing 22 Heated Mattress Pads, Here Are The Best We Recommend

• After Years of Testing Sleeper Sofas, These 5 Are the Best

• The 9 Best Bed Frames The Spruce Has Tested

1 of 4